Abstract:Decisions are faster and less accurate when conditions favor speed, and are slower and more accurate when they favor accuracy. This speed-accuracy trade-off (SAT) can be explained by the principles of bounded integration, where noisy evidence is integrated until it reaches a bound. Higher bounds reduce the impact of noise by increasing integration times, supporting higher accuracy (vice versa for speed). These computations are hypothesized to be implemented by feedback inhibition between neural populations selective for the decision alternatives, each of which corresponds to an attractor in the space of network states. Since decision-correlated neural activity typically reaches a fixed rate at the time of commitment to a choice, it has been hypothesized that the neural implementation of the bound is fixed, and that the SAT is supported by a common input to the populations integrating evidence. According to this hypothesis, a stronger common input reduces the difference between a baseline firing rate and a threshold rate for enacting a choice. In simulations of a two-choice decision task, we use a reduced version of a biophysically-based network model (Wong and Wang, 2006) to show that a common input can control the SAT but that changes to the threshold-baseline difference are epiphenomenal. Rather, the SAT is controlled by changes to network dynamics. A stronger common input decreases the model's effective time constant of integration and changes the shape of the attractor landscape, so the initial state is in a more error-prone position. Thus, a stronger common input reduces decision time and lowers accuracy. The change in dynamics also renders firing rates higher under speed conditions at the time that an ideal observer can make a decision from network activity. The difference between this rate and the baseline rate is actually greater under speed conditions than accuracy conditions, suggesting that the bound is not implemented by firing rates per se.

Decision making in noisy bistable systems with time-dependent asymmetry

Bridging time scales in cellular decision making with a stochastic bistable switch

A decision-making Fokker-Planck model in computational neuroscience

Interplay between Path and Speed in Decision Making by High-Dimensional Stochastic Gene Regulatory Networks

Noise-induced Dynamics in the Mixed-Feedback-loop Network Motif.

Network Structure and Input Integration in Competing Firing Rate Models for Decision-Making.

Dynamic Processes of Fate Decision in Inducible Bistable Systems

Bifurcations of a Birhythmic Model with Time Delays and Non-Gaussian Coloured Noise

The Dynamics of Bistable Switching Behavior in Limit Cycle Systems with Additive Noise

The stochastic behavior of a molecular switching circuit with feedback

Switch Dynamics for Stochastic Model of Genetic Toggle Switch

Modulating bifurcations in a self-sustained birhythmic system by α -stable Lévy noise and time delay

Phase transition and cascading collapse in binary decision-making dynamics

Extrinsic noise driven phenotype switching in a self-regulating gene

Strategic control for a Boltzmann like decision-making model

Mean first-passage time for an asymmetric bistable system driven by multiplicative and additive noise

Delay-induced Transitions in the Birhythmic Biological Model under Joint Noise Sources

Dynamics of Multiple-Choice Decision Making.

Modulating Bifurcations in a Self-Sustained Birhythmic System by $$\varvec{\alpha }$$-Stable Lévy Noise and Time Delay

Neural dynamics implement a flexible decision bound with a fixed firing rate for choice: a model-based hypothesis.

Quantifying the impact of network structure on speed and accuracy in collective decision-making