Abstract:Abstract : A topical issue in the context of the general debate about the need to retain or abolish forced share in Spain is the question of whether to broaden the range of grounds for excluding a forced heir from his or her share of the estate. There is particular debate surrounding the appropriateness of adding estrangement or the lack of a family relationship to the list of grounds, with the aim of increasing testamentary freedom. Some countries have a tendency to allow ties of affection to prevail over purely family or kinship ties in this matter, but sometimes at the cost of legal certainty and – since such a vague ground is not necessarily more respectful with freedom of testation – despite the risk that the courts may not always achieve the justice sought by a testator who wishes to disinherit a forced heir that shows no affection for her. This paper considers the different approaches to this topic between different legal systems. The Catalan and the German ones just represent extreme examples of radical different tendencies. In Spain, recent case law has provided new arguments for thinking about what the law says, how the courts interpret, and, finally, what the society expects. Resumée : Faut-il étendre les causes qui permettent d’exclure un héritier réservataire de sa part dans le patrimoine? Telle est une des questions brûlantes qui agitent le débat sur le maintien ou l’abolition de la réserve héréditaire en Espagne. Le débat porte en particulier sur le point de savoir s’il est opportun d’ajouter aux causes d’exclusion, la séparation ou l’absence de relations familiales, dans le but d’accroitre la liberté testamentaire. Certains pays ont tendance à faire prévaloir les liens affectifs sur les liens de famille ou de parenté, parfois au détriment de la sécurité juridique. Le caractère vague d’un tel motif ne respecte pas nécessairement la liberté de tester, parce qu’il n’est pas sûr que les tribunaux y parviendraient à l’objectif de justice recherché par le testateur qui souhaite déshériter un héritier réservataire lorsqu’il ne montre pas de proximité affective avec lui. Cet article met en évidence les différentes approches de cette question par différents systèmes juridiques. Le système catalan et le système allemand donnent par exemple des réponses radicalement différentes. En Espagne, la jurisprudence récente a fourni de nouveaux arguments pour réfléchir à ce que dit la loi, ce que les tribunaux donnent comme interprétation et, enfin, ce que la société attend.

Land inheritance rules: theory and cross-cultural analysis

Fair inheritance taxation

A Model of Enclosures: Coordination, Conflict, and Efficiency in the Transformation of Land Property Rights

The lucky and unlucky daughter: Gender, land inheritance and agrarian change in Ratanakiri, Cambodia

Sex Preference, Marriage of Heirs and Bequest Behaviour

The Clan and State in the Definition of Land Rights

Of families and inheritance: law and development in England before the Industrial Revolution

The Tie-Breaker Rule in Inheritance Tax Treaties: The Asymmetry of Taxing Rights by Migrants

The gender of inheritance in an upper-class family network: Dallas, 1895–1945

Digging the channels of inheritance: On how to distinguish between cultural and biological inheritance

The Right to a Compulsory Share in Inheritance as Part of Public International Order (in Connection with the Judgments of the ECHR of 15 February 2024)

Issues of Qualification of Legal Norms and Categories of the Donation Agreement for Future Property as Norms of the Concluded Inheritance Agreement

Inheritances, social classes, and wealth distribution

People’s Judgments About Classic Property Law Cases

Endowment Effects in Evolutionary Game Theory: Enhancing Property Rights

Kinship Bonds and Emotional Ties: Lack of a Family Relationship as Ground for Disinheritance

Acquiring Land from Traditional Communities: Bottlenecks, Misallocation, and Second-Best Considerations

Bequest As A Public Good Within Marriage - A Note

Gender Bias, Investments in Children, and Bequests

The Rules of the Game and the Uncertain Transmission of Advantage

An Evolutionary Analysis of the Assignment of Property Rights