Dynamical scalarization in Schwarzschild binary inspirals

Félix-Louis Julié

2023-12-28

Abstract:We show that Schwarzschild black hole binaries can undergo dynamical scalarization (DS) in the inspiral phase, in a subclass of $\mathbb{Z}_2$-symmetric Einstein-scalar-Gauss-Bonnet (ESGB) theories of gravity. The mechanism is analogous to neutron star DS in scalar-tensor gravity, and it differs from the late merger and ringdown black hole (de)scalarization found in recent ESGB studies. To our knowledge, the new parameter space we highlight was unexplored in numerical relativity simulations. We also estimate the orbital separation at the DS onset, and characterize the subsequent scalar hair growth at the adiabatic approximation.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores a new phenomenon—dynamical scalarization (DS)—that occurs during the merger of two Schwarzschild black holes in a specific class of Z_2 symmetric Einstein-scalar-Gauss-Bonnet (ESGB) gravity theories. This phenomenon is similar to the dynamical scalarization process observed in neutron stars within scalar-tensor gravity theories and occurs during the inspiral phase of black hole mergers.

Specifically, the main contributions of the paper include:

1. **Newly discovered dynamical scalarization mechanism**: The authors demonstrate that within a specific parameter space, a binary system of Schwarzschild black holes can undergo dynamical scalarization during the inspiral phase. This phenomenon is distinct from the dynamical scalarization observed in previous studies, which occurs in the late merger or ringdown stages.
2. **Theoretical background and analytical methods**: The study is based on a class of Z_2 symmetric ESGB gravity theories, considering solutions for non-rotating black holes, and explores the response of black holes to an external scalar field background through both analytical and numerical methods.
3. **Sensitivity parameters**: The authors define "sensitivity" parameters β^(1) and β^(3) to describe the response of black holes to a small but non-zero scalar background and calculate these parameters using two independent methods (analytical and numerical).
4. **Conditions for dynamical scalarization**: The paper identifies the parameter space in which dynamical scalarization occurs, including conditions such as the mass ratio of the two black holes and their proportional relationship to the Schwarzschild radius.
5. **Subsequent scalar hair growth**: The authors provide an approximate expression for the growth of scalar hair following the onset of dynamical scalarization and discuss how this growth varies with orbital separation.

This research provides a new perspective on the dynamics of black holes in ESGB gravity theories and points the way for future numerical relativity simulations. Additionally, this work lays the theoretical foundation for exploring other theories that include massive scalar fields.