Abstract:Fluctuation theorems are fundamental results in nonequilibrium thermodynamics beyond the linear response regime. Among these, the paradigmatic Tasaki-Crooks fluctuation theorem relates the statistics of the works done in a forward out-of-equilibrium quantum process and in a corresponding backward one. In particular, the initial states of the two processes are thermal states and thus incoherent in the energy basis. Here, we aim to investigate the role of initial quantum coherence in work fluctuation theorems, by considering a quasiprobability distribution of work. To do this, we formulate and examine the implications of a detailed fluctuation theorem, which reproduces the Tasaki-Crooks fluctuation theorem in the absence of initial quantum coherence.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to formulate and understand the Work Fluctuation Theorems (WFTs) in quantum thermodynamics when there is quantum coherence in the initial state. Specifically, the authors explored how to describe work statistics through quasiprobability distribution when the initial state has quantum coherence in the energy basis, and derived the corresponding Detailed Fluctuation Theorem (DFT), which can be reduced to the Tasaki - Crooks fluctuation theorem in the absence of initial quantum coherence.
### Core problems of the paper
1. **Influence of initial quantum coherence**:
- In the traditional work fluctuation theorems, the initial state is usually an incoherent state (i.e., a thermal state) in the energy basis. However, when the initial state contains quantum coherence, the traditional two - projection - measurement scheme will destroy this coherence, leading to inaccurate results.
- The authors describe work statistics by introducing quasiprobability distribution to preserve the influence of initial quantum coherence.
2. **Application of quasiprobability distribution**:
- The quasiprobability distribution can allow negative values, thus maintaining linear properties and being able to describe cases with initial quantum coherence.
- The authors derived a detailed fluctuation theorem, which is consistent with the Tasaki - Crooks fluctuation theorem in the absence of initial quantum coherence, but gives new results when there is initial quantum coherence.
3. **Time - reversal and contextuality**:
- The authors discussed the contextuality problem in the time - reversal process, that is, in some cases, quantum contextuality will appear in the time - reversal process, which does not exist in the traditional fluctuation theorems.
- By introducing the quasiprobability distribution, the authors showed how to deal with these non - classical features.
4. **Integral fluctuation theorems and bounds of work averages**:
- Starting from the detailed fluctuation theorem, the authors derived two integral fluctuation theorems, one of which has been proposed in the literature, and the other is a new result.
- These integral fluctuation theorems give the lower bounds of work averages, which are related to the quantum coherence of the initial and final states.
### Main contributions
- **Theoretical framework**: Proposed a theoretical framework based on quasiprobability distribution for describing work statistics with initial quantum coherence.
- **Detailed fluctuation theorem**: Derived a new detailed fluctuation theorem, which is consistent with the Tasaki - Crooks fluctuation theorem in the absence of initial quantum coherence, but gives new results when there is initial quantum coherence.
- **Integral fluctuation theorems**: Derived two integral fluctuation theorems from the detailed fluctuation theorem, and these theorems provide the lower bounds of work averages.
- **Physical significance**: Through these theorems, the authors revealed the influence of initial quantum coherence on quantum thermodynamic processes, especially how it affects work statistics and the emergence of the thermodynamic arrow.
### Formula summary
- **Tasaki - Crooks fluctuation theorem**:
\[
e^{-\beta(w - \Delta F)} p_{\text{TPM}}(w)=\bar{p}_{\text{TPM}}(-w)
\]
- **Quasiprobability distribution**:
\[
p_q(w)=\sum_{i, j, k} \operatorname{Re} \operatorname{Tr}(\Pi_i \rho \Pi_j \Pi_k') \delta\left(w - \epsilon_k' + q \epsilon_i+(1 - q) \epsilon_j\right)
\]
- **Detailed fluctuation theorem**:
\[
e^{-\beta(w - \Delta F)-C+\bar{C}} p_q(w, C, \bar{C})=\bar{p}_q(-w, \bar{C}, C)
\]
- **Integral fluctuation**