Abstract:In this paper, we study of the $m$-Capacitated Facility Location Problem ($m$-CFLP) on the line from a Bayesian Mechanism Design perspective and propose a novel class of mechanisms: the \textit{Extended Ranking Mechanisms} (ERMs). We first show that an ERM is truthful if and only if it satisfies a system of inequalities that depends on the capacities of the facilities we need to place. We then establish a connection between the $m$-CFLP and a norm minimization problem in the Wasserstein space, which enables us to show that if the number of agent goes to infinity the limit of the ratio between the expected Social Cost of an ERM and the expected optimal Social Cost is finite and characterize its value. Noticeably, our method generalizes to encompass other truthful mechanisms and other metrics, such as the $l_p$ and Maximum costs. We conclude our theoretical analysis by characterizing the optimal ERM tailored to a $m$-CFLP and a distribution $\mu$, that is the ERM whose limit Bayesian approximation ratio is the lowest compared to all other feasible ERMs. We consider mainly two frameworks: (i) in the first framework, the total facility capacity matches the number of agents, (ii) in the second framework, $m=2$. When we consider the Maximum Cost, we retrieve the optimal ERM for every $\mu$, while for the Social Cost, we characterize the solution when the measure $\mu$ is symmetric. Lastly, we numerically compare the performance of the ERMs against other truthful mechanisms and evaluate how quickly the Bayesian approximation ratio converges to its limit.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: from the perspective of Bayesian mechanism design, study the m - capacity facility location problem (m - CFLP) and propose a new mechanism category - Extended Ranking Mechanisms (ERMs). Specifically:
1. **Problem Background**:
- In traditional mechanism design, in order to ensure the truthfulness of the mechanism (that is, it is the optimal strategy for each agent to report its true information), it usually leads to sub - optimal results. Especially in the m - capacity facility location problem, when the number of facilities exceeds two, it becomes very difficult to find a truthful mechanism with a finite approximation ratio.
- Most of the existing research focuses on worst - case analysis. This method is too pessimistic and cannot provide effective guidance for selecting mechanisms for specific tasks.
2. **Paper Objectives**:
- By introducing the Bayesian mechanism design framework, assume that the location of each agent is a random variable with a known distribution, thereby transforming the problem into an expected cost minimization problem.
- Propose and study Extended Ranking Mechanisms (ERMs). These mechanisms can not only handle a wider range of scenarios (such as the case where the total capacity exceeds the number of agents), but also perform well in the expected sense.
- Analyze the properties of ERMs, including their truthfulness, optimality, and convergence, and compare them with existing mechanisms.
3. **Main Contributions**:
- Define and study Extended Ranking Mechanisms (ERMs), prove their truthfulness conditions, and give methods for optimizing ERMs.
- Establish the connection between m - CFLP and the norm minimization problem in Wasserstein space, and use the properties of Wasserstein distance to prove the convergence of the Bayesian approximation ratio.
- For different types of cost functions (such as maximum cost and social cost), provide sufficient conditions for optimal ERMs and develop algorithms for calculating optimal ERMs.
- Verify the performance of ERMs through numerical experiments, indicating that when the number of agents is large, ERMs perform better than other truthful mechanisms.
In summary, this paper aims to provide a new and more effective solution for the m - capacity facility location problem by introducing Bayesian mechanism design and Extended Ranking Mechanisms.