Hairpin Motors for Electromobility: Twists and Bends of a Technological Breakthrough that Initially Arrived A Century Too Soon

Stefan M. Goetz,Ricardo Lizana F.,Sebastian Rivera

2023-12-26

Abstract:There is currently a major trend to hairpin-winding motors for small and medium drives with increased power, specifically more torque density in the automotive industry. Practically all large players in the field either already use this winding technology or have announced doing so soon. However, hairpins, bar windings, and other segmented winding techniques are not purely a material and production issue. Instead their application to small drives influences all aspects of the design of machines, which are currently explored and studied by the industry. These range from not obvious gaps in the theory, parameter studies for maxima of efficiency, possible as well as advantageous winding schemes, thermal design, and ways to control ac losses to specific materials and process difficulties. Despite the apparent novelty of the trend, however, designers could revisit a widely forgotten knowledge base of more than 100 years for many of those questions. This old knowledge base and the understanding that many recently presented concepts have been developed earlier may speed up the technological development and appear to be a key to further innovation. Instead, many problems need to be solved again and technologies re-invented. Furthermore, as this technology has recently become merely industry-driven, a substantial portion of the information and technological developments are not available to the public -- a state that to our eyes may harm the innovation capacity of the drives community.

Systems and Control,Applied Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the historical development of hairpin motor winding technology and its applications and challenges in the modern automotive industry. Hairpin motor winding technology is a technique used to increase the power density of small and medium-sized drive units, especially in the automotive sector, enabling higher torque density. This paper aims to address the following key issues:

1. **Technical Review**: The paper reviews the development history of hairpin motor winding technology, from early explorations to modern applications, particularly its initial proposal and application in the late 19th century.

2. **Technical Advantages**: The paper discusses in detail the advantages of hairpin motor winding technology, including but not limited to automated production, high power density, efficient thermal management, and improved insulation performance.

3. **Historical Perspective**: The paper points out that although hairpin motor winding technology appears to be an emerging trend in modern times, many related concepts and technologies were actually developed more than a century ago. These early knowledge and technologies can provide valuable references and insights for current technological development.

4. **Modern Challenges**: As this technology has become industry-dominant in recent years, much information and technological development have not been publicly shared, which may limit the ability to innovate. Additionally, while hairpin motor winding technology has significant advantages, it also faces some new challenges, such as controlling high-frequency losses, researching optimal efficiency parameters, and developing effective cooling solutions.

5. **Technological Innovations**: The paper also mentions some recent technological innovations, such as direct liquid cooling methods, and how improving insulation materials and manufacturing processes can further enhance motor performance.

In summary, this paper aims to reveal the reasons why hairpin motor winding technology was overlooked in the past by reviewing its historical development process and to explore how to utilize this historical knowledge to accelerate current technological advancements and address modern challenges.