Normal Modes of the Stretched Horizon: A Bulk Mechanism for Black Hole Microstate Level Spacing

Chethan Krishnan,Pradipta S. Pathak
2023-12-22
Abstract:In 1984, 't Hooft famously used a brickwall (aka stretched horizon) to compute black hole entropy up to a numerical pre-factor. This calculation is sometimes interpreted as due to the entanglement of the modes across the horizon, but more operationally, it is simply an indirect count of the semi-classical modes trapped between the stretched horizon and the angular momentum barrier. Because the calculation was indirect, it needed both the mass and the temperature of the black hole as inputs, to reproduce the area. A more conventional statistical mechanics calculation should be able to get the entropy, once the ensemble is specified (say via the energy, in a microcanonical setting). In this paper, we explicitly compute black hole normal modes in various examples, numerically as well as (in various regimes) analytically. The explicit knowledge of normal modes allows us to reproduce $both$ the Hawking temperature as well as the entropy, once the charges are specified, making this a conventional statistical mechanics calculation. A quasi-degeneracy in the angular quantum numbers is directly responsible for the area scaling of the entropy, and is the key distinction between the Planckian black body calculation (volume scaling) and the 't Hooftian calculation (area scaling). We discuss the (rotating) BTZ case in detail and match the thermodynamic quantities $exactly$. Schwarzschild and Kerr normal modes are discussed in less detail using near-horizon approximations. Our calculations reveal a new hierarchy in the angular quantum numbers, which we speculate is related to string theory.
High Energy Physics - Theory
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on the statistical mechanical description of the microscopic states of black holes. Specifically: 1. **Calculation of black - hole entropy**: The paper tries to directly derive the temperature and entropy of a black hole from its mass by calculating the normal modes of the black hole. This is different from the traditional indirect calculation methods, which usually require specifying both the temperature and mass of the black hole simultaneously to obtain the entropy. The goal of the paper is to accurately calculate the temperature and entropy of the black hole only with the mass of the black hole as input by calculating the normal modes, thus achieving a more conventional statistical mechanical calculation. 2. **Calculation of normal modes**: The authors explicitly calculate the normal modes of black holes in various examples, including numerical calculations and analytical calculations (under certain approximations). The explicit knowledge of these normal modes enables them to reproduce the Hawking temperature and entropy once the charge of the black hole is specified. 3. **Quasi - degeneracy of quantum numbers**: The paper reveals that the quasi - degeneracy in the angular quantum number direction is a key factor leading to the change of entropy with area. This quasi - degeneracy is in contrast to the volume scaling in Planck's black - body radiation calculation, which is linear in all spatial directions. 4. **Diagnosis of quantum chaos**: Through the analysis of normal modes, the paper discovers a linear slope in the single - particle spectral form factor (SFF), which is considered as a diagnostic indicator of quantum chaos. The authors clearly identify the source of the slope in the normal modes through analytical approximation and relate it to the slope in the logarithmic spectrum mentioned in the literature. 5. **Importance of low - frequency modes**: The paper points out that it is these low - frequency modes that are responsible for the thermodynamic properties of black holes and the linear slope in the spectral form factor. The thermodynamic properties can be reproduced even if the weak \(J\)-dependence of the spectrum is ignored, while the linear slope is generated by the \(J\)-dependence. 6. **Physical meaning of mode cutoff**: The paper finds that in order to match the entropy, the normal modes automatically have a cutoff value, which is lower than the cutoff value in 't Hooft's calculation by a logarithmic factor \(\sim \log S_{\text{BH}}\). This finding not only enables them to accurately match the entropy and temperature but also reveals the relationship between these modes and the linear slope. The authors speculate that this mode cutoff may be related to the Hagedorn transition in string theory. In conclusion, by calculating the normal modes of black holes in detail, this paper provides a new method to understand the microscopic states of black holes and their thermodynamic properties, especially the calculation of entropy. This method not only verifies the correctness of traditional calculations but also provides a new perspective for further research on the quantum properties of black holes.