Multi-period Stochastic Network Design for Combined Natural Gas and Hydrogen Distribution

Umur Hasturk,Albert H. Schrotenboer,Kees Jan Roodbergen,Evrim Ursavas
2024-08-31
Abstract:Hydrogen is produced from water using renewable electricity. Unlike electricity, hydrogen can be stored in large quantities for long periods. This storage ability acts as a green battery, allowing solar and wind energy to be generated and used at different times. As a result, green hydrogen plays a central role in facilitating a climate-neutral economy. However, the logistics for hydrogen are complex. As new hydrogen pipelines are developed for hydrogen, there is a trend toward repurposing the natural gas network for hydrogen, due to its economic and environmental benefits. Yet, a rapid conversion could disrupt the balance of natural gas supply and demand. Furthermore, technical and economic developments surrounding the transition contribute additional complexity, which introduces uncertainty in future supply and demand levels for both commodities. To address these challenges, we introduce a multi-period stochastic network design problem for the transition of a natural gas pipeline network into a green hydrogen pipeline network. We develop a progressive hedging based matheuristic to solve the problem. Results demonstrate our matheuristic is efficient, both in computation time and in solution quality. We show that factoring in uncertainty avoids premature expansion and ensures the development of an adequate pipeline network meeting long-term needs. In a case study in the Northern Netherlands for Hydrogen Energy Applications in Valley Environments for Northern Netherlands initiative, we focus on two key scenarios: local production and importation, exploring their impacts on performance indicators. Our case insights exemplify the solid foundation for strategic decision-making in energy transitions through our approach.
Optimization and Control
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to effectively gradually convert the existing natural gas pipeline network into a green hydrogen pipeline network in multi - period stochastic network design. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects: 1. **Uncertainty handling**: Due to the uncertainties in future hydrogen and natural gas demand and supply levels, how to consider these uncertainties in the planning process, avoid premature or excessive expansion, and ensure that long - term network requirements are met. 2. **Multi - commodity network design**: Research on how to handle multiple commodities (such as natural gas and hydrogen) simultaneously in a network, especially how to optimize the network design and use during the transition from one commodity to another. 3. **Cost and efficiency**: Develop a heuristic method based on the progressive hedging algorithm to solve the multi - period stochastic network design problem, ensuring that the solution is efficient in terms of both computation time and solution quality. 4. **Strategic decision support**: Through case studies, especially the Hydrogen Energy Applications in the Northern Netherlands (HEAVENN) project, explore network design strategies under different scenarios (such as local production and import), providing strategic decision support for energy transformation. ### Main contributions of the paper 1. **Introduction of new arc - sharing settings**: In the multi - period stochastic fixed - cost capacitated multi - commodity network design problem, a new arc - sharing setting is proposed, ensuring that each pipeline can be used for any commodity, but is only assigned to one commodity in a specific period and operates in its independent network. 2. **Extension of incremental network design**: Extend the existing incremental network design model to a multi - commodity framework, which not only considers multi - period strategic decisions, but also combines inventory management to reflect an efficient way of handling the seasonality of the energy market. 3. **Seasonal planning**: Through storage decisions, enable the model to conduct seasonal planning, using excess capacity in summer to ensure sufficient supply in winter. 4. **Algorithm improvement**: Enhance the progressive hedging algorithm to make it applicable to a wider range of two - stage recourse models, improving the efficiency and scalability of the algorithm. 5. **Actual case analysis**: Through the HEAVENN project in the northern Netherlands, compare the two main scenarios of local production and import, analyze the transition process from natural gas to hydrogen, and provide valuable insights for practical applications. In summary, this paper aims to solve the complex problems in the transition from natural gas networks to hydrogen networks through multi - period stochastic network design methods, providing technical support for achieving a climate - neutral economy.