Abstract:Decision-makers often observe the occurrence of events through a reporting process. City governments, for example, rely on resident reports to find and then resolve urban infrastructural problems such as fallen street trees, flooded basements, or rat infestations. Without additional assumptions, there is no way to distinguish events that occur but are not reported from events that truly did not occur--a fundamental problem in settings with positive-unlabeled data. Because disparities in reporting rates correlate with resident demographics, addressing incidents only on the basis of reports leads to systematic neglect in neighborhoods that are less likely to report events. We show how to overcome this challenge by leveraging the fact that events are spatially correlated. Our framework uses a Bayesian spatial latent variable model to infer event occurrence probabilities and applies it to storm-induced flooding reports in New York City, further pooling results across multiple storms. We show that a model accounting for under-reporting and spatial correlation predicts future reports more accurately than other models, and further induces a more equitable set of inspections: its allocations better reflect the population and provide equitable service to non-white, less traditionally educated, and lower-income residents. This finding reflects heterogeneous reporting behavior learned by the model: reporting rates are higher in Census tracts with higher populations, proportions of white residents, and proportions of owner-occupied households. Our work lays the groundwork for more equitable proactive government services, even with disparate reporting behavior.

A Bayesian Spatial Model to Correct Under-Reporting in Urban Crowdsourcing

Quantifying spatial under-reporting disparities in resident crowdsourcing

Bayesian statistics in spatial epidemiology]

Bayesian Network Regularized Regression for Modeling Urban Crime Occurrences

Spatio-Temporal Analysis of Urban Crime Leveraging Multisource Crowdsensed Data

An Incentive Mechanism Based on a Bayesian Game for Spatial Crowdsourcing.

A Bayesian hierarchical small-area population model accounting for data source specific methodologies from American Community Survey, Population Estimates Program, and Decennial Census data

Correcting misclassification errors in crowdsourced ecological data: A Bayesian perspective

Dynamic road crime risk prediction with urban open data

ESCORT: Fine-Grained Urban Crime Risk Inference Leveraging Heterogeneous Open Data

Bayesian nonparametric boundary detection for income areal data

Modeling Rape Reporting Delays Using Spatial, Temporal and Social Features

Spatial Modeling of Trends in Crime over Time in Philadelphia

Bayesian Heatmaps: Probabilistic Classification with Multiple Unreliable Information Sources

A Computational Cognitive Modeling Approach to Understand and Design Mobile Crowdsourcing for Campus Safety Reporting

The Bayesian Spatial Bradley--Terry Model: Urban Deprivation Modeling in Tanzania

Assessing Spatial Disparities: A Bayesian Linear Regression Approach

The Bayesian Spatial Bradley–Terry model: Urban deprivation modelling in Tanzania

Bayesian Inference for Finite Populations Under Spatial Process Settings

A Bayesian machine learning model for estimating building occupancy from open source data

Bayesian Modeling of Incompatible Spatial Data: A Case Study Involving Post-Adrian Storm Forest Damage Assessment