Abstract:Metcalfe's Law captures the relationship between the value of a network and its scale, asserting that a network's value is directly proportional to the square of its size. Over the past four decades, various researchers have proposed different scaling laws on this subject. Remarkably, these seemingly conflicting conclusions have all been substantiated by robust data validation, raising the question of which law holds greater representativeness. Consequently, there remains a need for inherent mechanism to underpin these laws. This study aims to bridge this disparity by offering a theoretical interpretation of Metcalfe's Law and its variations. Based on a certain degree of consensus that "traffic is value", network effects are gauged using network traffic load. A general analytical boundary for network traffic load is deduced by balancing practicality and analytical feasibility through the establishment of a comprehensive network model. From this foundation, the mechanism behind Metcalfe's Law and its variants is elucidated, aligning the theoretical derivations with the previously validated empirical evidence for Metcalfe's Law.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the applicability and representativeness of Metcalfe’s Law and its variants in the relationship between network value and scale. Specifically, the paper aims to: 1. **Explain the applicability of different network laws**: In the past 40 years, many studies have proposed different network expansion laws. These laws seem contradictory to each other but have all been verified by data. Therefore, an internal mechanism is required to uniformly explain these laws and determine which law is more representative. 2. **Establish a theoretical framework**: The paper proposes the principle of "traffic is value" and measures network effects through network traffic load. By establishing a comprehensive network model and achieving a balance between practicality and analytical feasibility, the general analytical boundaries of network traffic load are derived. 3. **Reveal the mechanisms behind Metcalfe’s Law and its variants**: Theoretically explain the mechanisms of these laws and their variants, making the theoretical derivation consistent with the previously verified empirical data. 4. **Solve the unsolved problems in current research**: By establishing a series of mechanisms to reproduce these laws, we can better understand the relationship between network value and scale and achieve a true understanding of the universality of this research. ### Main contributions of the paper - **Introduce a new perspective**: Use network traffic as a basic indicator to measure network value, emphasizing the principle of "traffic is value". - **Construct a two - layer network model**: Including the underlying physical transmission and the upper - level device/user interaction, focusing on the information transmission load at the upper level. - **Derive the theoretical boundaries of traffic load**: By combining four aspects: node influence distribution, data destination distribution, relationship separation distribution, and network geographical distribution, the theoretical boundaries of traffic load are derived. - **Verify Metcalfe’s Law and its variants**: Through the fitting of actual network data, verify the applicability of Metcalfe’s Law and its variants under different conditions. ### Conclusion By establishing theoretical models and mechanisms, the paper explains the performance of Metcalfe’s Law and its variants in network traffic load and shows the applicability and unique significance of these laws in different scenarios. This provides valuable insights for exploring new expansion laws in the future.

Emergence of Metcalfe's Law: Mechanism and Model

Tencent and Facebook Data Validate Metcalfe’s Law

Modeling and Analysis of Resource'S Load-Scale in P2p Network

An Evolving Model of Online Bipartite Networks

Metcalfe’s Law and Network Quality: An Extension of Zhang et al.

METCALFE’S LAW IN THE DIGITAL MEDIA MARKET

Emergence of Scale-Free Close-Knit Friendship Structure in Online Social Networks

Enzymatic Origin and Various Curvatures of Metabolic Scaling in Microbes

The Emergence of Scaling Law, Fractal Patterns and Small-World in Wireless Networks

Mandelbrot Law of Evolving Networks

Modelling the growth of the network value

Geometric origin of scaling in large traffic networks

On the Emerging of Scaling Law, Fractality and Small-World in Cellular Networks.

Metcalfe's Law as a Model for Bitcoin's Value

Evaluating Network Models: A Likelihood Analysis

Scaling Behaviors of Traffic in Computer Communication Networks

Emergence and disappearance of traffic congestion in weight-evolving networks

Measurement-Driven Modeling for Connection Density and Traffic Distribution in Large-Scale Urban Mobile Networks.

Network Behavior Analysis Based On A Computer Network Model

Scaling behavior of an artificial traffic model on scale-free networks

The Accumulative Law and Its Probability Model: an Extension of the Pareto Distribution and the Log-Normal Distribution.