Abstract:Many policies allocate harms or benefits that are uncertain in nature: they produce distributions over the population in which individuals have different probabilities of incurring harm or benefit. Comparing different policies thus involves a comparison of their corresponding probability distributions, and we observe that in many instances the policies selected in practice are hard to explain by preferences based only on the expected value of the total harm or benefit they produce. In cases where the expected value analysis is not a sufficient explanatory framework, what would be a reasonable model for societal preferences over these distributions? Here we investigate explanations based on the framework of probability weighting from the behavioral sciences, which over several decades has identified systematic biases in how people perceive probabilities. We show that probability weighting can be used to make predictions about preferences over probabilistic distributions of harm and benefit that function quite differently from expected-value analysis, and in a number of cases provide potential explanations for policy preferences that appear hard to motivate by other means. In particular, we identify optimal policies for minimizing perceived total harm and maximizing perceived total benefit that take the distorting effects of probability weighting into account, and we discuss a number of real-world policies that resemble such allocational strategies. Our analysis does not provide specific recommendations for policy choices, but is instead interpretive in nature, seeking to describe observed phenomena in policy choices.

Better Foundations for Subjective Probability

Subjective probability and decision under uncertainty.

Imprecise Probabilities From Imprecise Descriptions Of Real Numbers

Studies in subjective probability l: Prediction of random events

On a generalised form of subjective probability

Predicting the Unpredictable under Subjective Expected Utility

Gambling under unknown probabilities as a proxy for real world decisions under uncertainty

Surreal Decisions

Decision Theory with Imprecise Probabilities

Decision-making Under Ordinal Preferences and Comparative Uncertainty

Probabilistic Representation Differences between Decisions from Description and Decisions from Experience

Expected utility theory with probability grids and preference formation

Logic of subjective probability

Dynamically Consistent Objective and Subjective Rationality

Subjective Complexity Under Uncertainty

Exceeding Expectations: Stochastic Dominance as a General Decision Theory

Subjective Expected Utility and Psychological Gambles

Eliciting Subjective Probabilities Through Exchangeable Events: An Advantage and a Limitation

Probability Premium and Attitude Towards Probability

On modeling human perceptions of allocation policies with uncertain outcomes

Decision-Making Under Uncertainty: Beyond Probabilities