Abstract:Thought experiments are where logical reasoning meets storytelling, catalysing progress in quantum science and technology. Schrödinger's famous cat brought quantum science to the public consciousness, while Deutsch's thought experiment to test the many-worlds and Copenhagen interpretations involved the first conception of a quantum computer. I will show how presenting thought experiments using quantum circuits can demystify apparent quantum paradoxes, and provide fun, conceptually important activities for learners to implement themselves on near-term quantum devices. Additionally, I will explain how thought experiments can be used as a first introduction to quantum, and outline a workshop based on the "quantum bomb tester" for school students as young as 11. This paper draws upon my experience in developing and delivering quantum computing workshops in Oxford, and in creating a quantum paradoxes content series with IBM Quantum of videos, blogs and code tutorials.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve
The paper attempts to address the issue of how to understand and explain quantum thought experiments through quantum circuits, thereby helping students and beginners better grasp the core concepts of quantum mechanics. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects:
1. **Simplifying Quantum Paradoxes**: By converting quantum thought experiments into quantum circuits, the paper aims to eliminate some seemingly contradictory quantum phenomena, making these complex concepts easier to understand.
2. **Educational Tool**: The paper explores how quantum thought experiments can be used as educational tools, particularly how hands-on manipulation of quantum circuits can enhance students' understanding and interest.
3. **Introducing Quantum Computing**: The paper proposes a workshop based on the "quantum bomb tester" thought experiment, suitable for students as young as 11 years old, to introduce the basic concepts of quantum science and technology.
4. **Unified Explanation**: The paper demonstrates how different quantum thought experiments can be uniformly explained through quantum circuits, revealing their intrinsic connections.
### Main Thought Experiments and Their Explanations
1. **Schrödinger's Cat**:
- **Background**: Schrödinger's cat is a famous quantum thought experiment that describes a cat in a box with a vial of poison. If a radioactive atom decays, the vial will break, and the cat will die.
- **Quantum Circuit Explanation**: By modeling the radioactive atom, the cat, and the observer as quantum systems and using quantum gates (such as Hadamard gates and CNOT gates) to simulate their interactions, it can be shown that the existence of macroscopic superposition states is not contradictory. The introduction of the environment further explains why the observer can only perceive a single outcome (i.e., the cat is either alive or dead), which is due to the decoherence process.
2. **Wigner's Friend**:
- **Background**: Wigner's friend thought experiment explores the nature of quantum measurement. Wigner's friend measures a quantum system in a superposition state, and then Wigner asks the friend about the result.
- **Quantum Circuit Explanation**: By modeling the friend's memory and the quantum system as qubits and using CNOT gates to simulate the measurement process, it can be shown how the memories of the two observers form an entangled state. This reveals the self-consistency of the measurement problem, where each observer encounters a definite measurement result without contradiction.
3. **Testing the Many-Worlds Interpretation vs. the Copenhagen Interpretation**:
- **Background**: Deutsch's thought experiment aims to test whether quantum measurement is reversible (many-worlds interpretation) or irreversible (Copenhagen interpretation).
- **Quantum Circuit Explanation**: By simulating an observer measuring a quantum system in a superposition state and then attempting to reverse the measurement, it can be verified whether the superposition state of the quantum system is restored. If the measurement is reversible, it supports the many-worlds interpretation; if it is irreversible, it supports the Copenhagen interpretation.
4. **Double-Slit Experiment**:
- **Background**: The double-slit experiment is a standard example of wave-particle duality in quantum physics. When a single photon passes through two slits, it forms an interference pattern on the screen, but if the photon's path is observed, the interference pattern disappears.
- **Quantum Circuit Explanation**: By using the quantum circuit model of a Mach-Zehnder interferometer, it can be shown how photons form an interference pattern in the absence of detectors, while exhibiting particle behavior in the presence of detectors. This reveals that any interaction with the environment destroys the interference, thus explaining the mechanism of wave-particle duality.
5. **Delayed-Choice Quantum Eraser Experiment**:
- **Background**: The delayed-choice quantum eraser experiment is a complex version of Wheeler's delayed-choice experiment, which seems to suggest that current measurements can retroactively determine the past behavior of a quantum system.
- **Quantum Circuit Explanation**: By using a detector qubit to store information about which slit the photon passed through and then separating different patterns in the data on the screen, the interference pattern can be restored. This shows that even long after the photon has been detected, the choice of measurement method can change its behavior.
### Conclusion
By converting quantum thought experiments into quantum circuits, the paper not only provides new insights into the core concepts of quantum mechanics but also offers an interesting and intuitive learning method for education and beginners. This approach helps demystify quantum paradoxes, allowing students to deepen their understanding of quantum science through hands-on manipulation of quantum devices.