Abstract:Residential electric water heaters have significant load shifting capabilities due to their thermal heat capacity and large energy consumption. Model predictive control (MPC) has been shown to be an effective control strategy to enable water heater load shifting in home energy management systems. In this work, we analyze how modeling tank stratification in an MPC formulation impacts control performance for stratified electric water heaters under time-of-use (TOU) rates. Specifically, we propose an MPC formulation based on a three-node thermal model that captures tank stratification, and compare it to a one-node formulation that does not capture stratification and a standard thermostatic controller. These strategies are compared through both real-time laboratory testing and simulation-based evaluation for different water use patterns. Laboratory experiments show cost reductions of 12.3-23.2% for the one-node MPC and 31.2-42.5% for the three-node MPC relative to the thermostatic controller. The performance of the one-node MPC is limited by significant plant-model mismatch, while the three-node formulation better approximates real-world dynamics and results in much more effective cost reduction and load shifting. A simple analysis of how each strategy performs under water use forecast errors is also provided.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is improving the load flexibility of stratified electric water heaters under Time-of-Use (TOU) pricing. Specifically, the authors analyze the impact of considering tank stratification on control performance in a Model Predictive Control (MPC) strategy. The paper proposes an MPC strategy based on a three-node thermal model that can capture the stratification phenomenon within the tank and compares it with a single-node model that does not consider stratification and a traditional thermostat controller. The control performance under different water usage patterns is studied through laboratory tests and simulation evaluations. ### Main Research Content: 1. **Background and Motivation**: - Residential electric water heaters have significant load-shifting capabilities due to their large thermal capacity and high energy consumption. - Model Predictive Control (MPC) has been proven to be an effective control strategy for achieving load shifting in water heaters. - This paper specifically focuses on how considering tank stratification in stratified electric water heaters affects control performance in an MPC strategy. 2. **Methods**: - **Model**: A three-node thermal model-based MPC strategy is proposed, which can capture the stratification phenomenon within the tank. - **Comparison**: The three-node MPC strategy is compared with a single-node MPC strategy that does not consider stratification and a traditional thermostat controller. - **Experiments**: The control performance under different water usage patterns is validated through laboratory tests and simulation evaluations. 3. **Results**: - Experimental results show that compared to the thermostat controller, the cost reduction rate of the single-node MPC strategy is 12.3%-23.2%, while the cost reduction rate of the three-node MPC strategy is 31.2%-42.5%. - The single-node MPC strategy is limited in performance due to significant model-actual system mismatches, whereas the three-node model better approximates the actual system dynamics, achieving more effective cost reduction and load shifting. 4. **Contributions**: - A new three-node MPC strategy is proposed, which improves control performance while maintaining computational tractability. - A parameter identification method is developed and validated using actual measurement data. - A laboratory test platform is designed to validate different control strategies under actual conditions. - Through laboratory tests and simulations, the performance of the proposed controller is compared in detail with the single-node MPC strategy and the thermostat controller. ### Conclusion: By proposing and validating an MPC strategy based on a three-node thermal model, this paper demonstrates the important role of considering tank stratification in improving the load flexibility of stratified electric water heaters. The research results show that the three-node MPC strategy can significantly reduce electricity costs and effectively achieve load shifting under TOU pricing. These findings are of great significance for optimizing water heater control strategies in home energy management systems.

Improving the Load Flexibility of Stratified Electric Water Heaters: Design and Experimental Validation of MPC Strategies

Designing model predictive control strategies for grid-interactive water heaters for load shifting applications

Model Predictive Control of a Solar Power System with Microturbine and Thermochemical Energy Storage

Field experiment testing of a low-cost model predictive controller (MPC) for building heating systems and analysis of phase change material (PCM) integration

Model Predictive Control for the Operation of a Transcritical CO2 Air Source Heat Pump Water Heater

Data-Driven Model Identification and Efficient MPC Via Quasi-Linear Parameter Varying Representation for ORC Waste Heat Recovery System

A Comparison of Model-Free and Model Predictive Control for Price Responsive Water Heaters

Real-time Multi-Variable Optimization of the Interstage Subcooling Vapor-Injection Based Transcritical CO2 HPWH: an Integrated Model Predictive Control Approach

Evaluation of model predictive control (MPC) of solar thermal heating system with thermal energy storage for buildings with highly variable occupancy levels

Operational optimization of residential HVAC system using model predictive control strategy planning

Field test of Model Predictive Control in residential buildings for utility cost savings

Performance Improvement of Air-Source Heat Pump Heating System with Variable Water Temperature Difference

Model Predictive Control Design for Unlocking the Energy Flexibility of Heat Pump and Thermal Energy Storage Systems

MPC using mixed-integer programming for aquifer thermal energy storages

Data-driven Identification and Fast Model Predictive Control of the ORC Waste Heat Recovery System by Using Koopman Operator

Validation of a Model Predictive Control Strategy on a High Fidelity Building Emulator

Analysis of predicted mean vote-based model predictive control for residential HVAC systems

Unveiling overlooked aspects of model predictive control for building air conditioning systems

A model predictive control strategy to optimize the performance of radiant floor heating and cooling systems in office buildings

Enhancing fuel cell performance through a dual MPC strategy for coordinated temperature management

Heuristic model predictive control implementation to activate energy flexibility in a fully electric school building