On the Role of the Action Space in Robot Manipulation Learning and Sim-to-Real Transfer

Elie Aljalbout,Felix Frank,Maximilian Karl,Patrick van der Smagt
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/LRA.2024.3398428
2024-04-30
Abstract:We study the choice of action space in robot manipulation learning and sim-to-real transfer. We define metrics that assess the performance, and examine the emerging properties in the different action spaces. We train over 250 reinforcement learning~(RL) agents in simulated reaching and pushing tasks, using 13 different control spaces. The choice of spaces spans combinations of common action space design characteristics. We evaluate the training performance in simulation and the transfer to a real-world environment. We identify good and bad characteristics of robotic action spaces and make recommendations for future designs. Our findings have important implications for the design of RL algorithms for robot manipulation tasks, and highlight the need for careful consideration of action spaces when training and transferring RL agents for real-world robotics.
Robotics,Machine Learning
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper aims to study the issue of action space selection in robot operation learning and simulation-to-reality transfer. Specifically: 1. **Explore the characteristics of different action spaces**: The authors define metrics for evaluating performance and examine the attributes that appear in different action spaces. 2. **Train a large number of Reinforcement Learning (RL) agents**: Train over 250 RL agents in a simulated environment to complete tasks of grasping and pushing objects, using 13 different control spaces. 3. **Evaluate training performance and reality transfer**: Evaluate training performance in the simulated environment and transfer the learned strategies to the real environment for testing. 4. **Identify good and bad action space features**: Identify the pros and cons in the design of robot action spaces and provide suggestions for future designs. These findings are significant for designing RL algorithms suitable for robot operation tasks and emphasize the importance of carefully considering action spaces when training and transferring RL agents for real-world robot applications. Through this research, the authors hope to fill the understanding gap in existing methods regarding simulation-to-reality transfer, thereby promoting the practicality of this technology in more application scenarios.