Abstract:Direct numerical simulations of turbulent pipe flow with transverse wall oscillation (WWO) and with no transverse wall oscillation (NWO) are carried out at friction Reynolds numbers Re{\tau} = 170, 360, and 720. The period and amplitude of the oscillation are selected to achieve high drag reduction in this Reynolds number range, and the effect of increasing Reynolds number on the amount of drag reduction achievable is analyzed. Of a particular interest in this study is the identification of the scales of motion most affected by drag reduction at different Reynolds numbers. To answer this question, both one-dimensional and two-dimensional spectra of different statistical quantities are analyzed with and without transverse wall oscillation. The effect of wall oscillation is found to suppress the intermediate- and large-scale motions in the buffer layer of the flow, while large-scale and very-large-scale motions in the log layer and the wake region are enhanced. While suppression of the near-wall turbulence promotes drag reduction, enhancement of the large-scale motions in the log and the wake region is found to oppose drag reduction. Since higher Reynolds number flows support development of a growing range of large-scale structures, it is suggested that their prevalence in the energy spectra combined with their negative effect on drag reduction account for a reduced effectiveness of wall oscillation as a drag reduction mechanism with increasing Reynolds numbers.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve
This paper aims to explore the influence of Reynolds number on the reduction of pipe turbulent drag achieved by Transverse Wall Oscillation (WWO). Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects:
1. **Effect of drag reduction**: Research on the effect of transverse wall oscillation on the reduction of pipe turbulent drag at different Reynolds numbers. In particular, as the Reynolds number increases, whether the effectiveness of drag reduction decreases and what the reasons for this decrease are.
2. **Influence of motion scales**: Analyze the influence of transverse wall oscillation on different - scale motions in the flow at different Reynolds numbers. Specifically, study which scales of motion are suppressed or enhanced and how these changes affect the effect of drag reduction.
3. **Energy spectra and statistics**: Through one - dimensional and two - dimensional spectral analyses, study the influence of transverse wall oscillation on the energy distribution of various statistics (such as velocity, shear stress, etc.) in the flow at different Reynolds numbers.
### Background and importance
- **Importance of drag reduction**: In many practical applications, such as airplanes, submarines and pipeline transportation, the proportion of surface frictional drag in the total drag is very high. Therefore, reducing surface frictional drag is the key to improving system efficiency.
- **Limitations of existing research**: Most research on drag reduction focuses on the lower Reynolds number range, while the Reynolds numbers in practical applications are usually much higher. Therefore, understanding the drag reduction mechanism at high Reynolds numbers is of great significance.
- **Advantages of transverse wall oscillation**: As a flow control technique, transverse wall oscillation has the advantages of relatively simple experimental and simulation settings, not introducing complex physical processes, etc., and can achieve a relatively high drag reduction effect (30% - 50%).
### Research methods
- **Numerical simulation**: Use the Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS) method to simulate pipe turbulence at different Reynolds numbers, including cases with and without transverse wall oscillation.
- **Parameter setting**: Select three different frictional Reynolds numbers \( \text{Re}_\tau= 170, 360, 720 \) and fix the non - dimensional amplitude \( W_0^+ = 10 \) and period \( T_0^+ = 100 \) of wall oscillation.
- **Data analysis**: Through one - dimensional and two - dimensional spectral analyses, study the influence of transverse wall oscillation on different - scale motions in the flow at different Reynolds numbers and how these changes affect the effect of drag reduction.
### Main findings
- **Effectiveness of drag reduction**: As the Reynolds number increases, the effect of transverse wall oscillation on drag reduction gradually decreases. For example, at \( \text{Re}_\tau = 170, 360, 720 \), the percentages of drag reduction are 28.8%, 26.0% and 22.9% respectively.
- **Changes in motion scales**: Transverse wall oscillation mainly suppresses medium - scale and large - scale motions in the buffer layer, while enhancing large - scale and very large - scale motions in the logarithmic layer and wake region. These changes have opposite effects on the effect of drag reduction.
- **Challenges at high Reynolds numbers**: As the Reynolds number increases, the range of large - scale structures supported in the flow gradually expands. The existence of these structures has a negative impact on drag reduction, resulting in a decrease in the effectiveness of transverse wall oscillation.
### Conclusion
This study reveals the mechanism of the decrease in the effect of transverse wall oscillation on the reduction of pipe turbulent drag at high Reynolds numbers, mainly due to the increase in large - scale structures at high Reynolds numbers, which have a negative impact on drag reduction. This finding provides a theoretical basis for improving flow control techniques at high Reynolds numbers.