Density-Jump Transitions in the Debye-Hückel Theory of Spin Ice and Electrolytes

Omar J. Abbas,Steven T. Bramwell,Daan M. Arroo

2023-12-05

Abstract:Debye-Hückel theory, originally developed to describe dilute electrolyte solutions, has proved particularly successful as a description of magnetic monopoles in spin ice systems such as Dy$_{2}$Ti$_{2}$O$_{7}$. For this model, Ryzhkin et al. [JETP Lett. 95, 302-306 (2012)] predicted a phase transition in which the monopole density abruptly changes by several orders of magnitude but to date this transition has not been observed experimentally. Here we confirm that this transition is a robust prediction of Debye-Hückel theory, that does not rely on approximations made in the previous work. However, we also find that the transition occurs in a regime where the theory breaks downs as a description of a Coulomb fluid and may be plausibly interpreted as an indicator of monopole crystallisation. By extending Ryzhkin's model, we associate the density jump of Debye-Hückel theory with the monopole crystallisation observed in staggered-potential models of `magnetic moment fragmentation', as well as with crystallisation in conserved monopole-density models. The possibility of observing a true density-jump transition in real spin ice and electrolyte systems is discussed.

Strongly Correlated Electrons,Statistical Mechanics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether the predicted magnetic monopole density jump transition can be experimentally observed within the framework of the Debye - Hückel theory. Specifically:

1. **Discrepancy between theory and experiment**: Earlier works (such as Ryzhkin et al.) used the Debye - Hückel theory to predict that at a specific temperature (for example, approximately 0.1887 K in Ho₂Ti₂O₇), the density of magnetic monopoles would change suddenly by several orders of magnitude. However, despite numerous experimental studies, this transition has not yet been observed in actual spin - ice systems.

2. **Re - evaluation of the theory**: The author re - evaluated the Debye - Hückel theory, specifically removing some approximations in previous works, to determine whether these approximations introduced non - existent phase transitions or simply shifted the phase transitions to parameter ranges that have not yet been experimentally explored.

3. **Physical mechanism of the phase transition**: The paper explored whether this density - jump transition can be interpreted as a precursor to the crystallization of magnetic monopoles. Specifically, the author found that when the parameters of the system enter the region where the Debye - Hückel theory fails, the crystallization of magnetic monopoles may occur, which may be one of the reasons why the phase transition has not been observed in experiments.

4. **Application of the extended model**: The author also explored whether there are similar phase transitions in other systems (such as electrolytes) and discussed how to explain the crystallization phenomenon in spin - ice systems by introducing the staggered potential.

In summary, this paper aims to explain why the theoretically predicted phase transition has not been observed in experiments by re - evaluating the Debye - Hückel theory and to explore the relationship between this phase transition and the crystallization of magnetic monopoles.