Abstract:Inspired by Conti and Zanzotto \cite{Conti2004A}, we reformulate a simple variational model for reconstructive phase transitions in crystals arising in continuum mechanics in the framework of Landau's theory of phase transition(with slight modification). We provide and prove that this class of modular invariant functions admit exactly hexagonal-square lattices minimizers without passing through rhombic lattices, being the first rigorous result in this regard. Our result gives an affirmative answer to an open problem by in \cite{Conti2004A}. In addition, our result has independent interest from number theory.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the problem of mathematical modeling of the phase transition from hexagonal to square lattice in continuum mechanics. Specifically, the authors aim to construct a strain energy function that can describe the transition of a crystal from a hexagonal lattice to a square lattice with temperature changes, without passing through a rhombic lattice.
### Background of the Paper
1. **Continuum Mechanics and Lattice Phase Transition**:
- Crystals can undergo phase transitions under different conditions, such as from a hexagonal lattice to a square lattice.
- This phase transition can be described by a strain energy function, which depends on the deformation gradient of the lattice and the Cauchy-Green tensor.
2. **Landau Phase Transition Theory**:
- Landau proposed the phase transition theory in 1936, explaining phase transition phenomena by finding the minimum of the energy density function.
- This theory requires the energy density function to have certain symmetries, which in 2D crystals are further determined by the SL(2, Z) group.
### Objectives of the Paper
1. **Constructing a Strain Energy Function**:
- Construct a strain energy function that satisfies specific conditions, such that when parameters (like "temperature") change, the global minimum of the function is always a hexagonal or square lattice, without passing through a rhombic lattice.
2. **Solving an Open Problem**:
- Address an open problem posed by Conti and Zanzotto, which is to find a strain energy function such that as parameters change, the system goes through the following three stages:
- Hexagonal lattice is unstable, square lattice is the global minimum.
- Both hexagonal and square lattices are local minima.
- Square lattice is unstable, hexagonal lattice is the global minimum.
### Main Results
1. **Form of the Strain Energy Function**:
- The authors constructed a new strain energy function in the form:
\[
\sum_{P \in L, |L|=1} |P|^2 e^{-\pi \alpha |P|^2}
\]
- This function satisfies the required symmetries and phase transition characteristics.
2. **Rigorous Proof**:
- Through rigorous mathematical analysis, the authors proved that this strain energy function indeed realizes the phase transition from hexagonal to square lattice within different parameter ranges, without passing through a rhombic lattice.
3. **Numerical Results**:
- Numerical calculations determined the critical parameter values \(\alpha_a\) and \(\alpha_b\) for the phase transition, which are 0.8947042694 and 0.9203340927, respectively.
### Conclusion
By constructing a new strain energy function and providing rigorous mathematical proof, this paper successfully addresses the modeling problem of the phase transition from hexagonal to square lattice, providing an important theoretical foundation for research in the related field.