Olga Viberg,René F. Kizilcec,Ioana Jivet,Alejandra Martínez Monés,Alice Oh,Chantal Mutimukwe,Stefan Hrastinski,Maren Scheffel
Abstract:Applications of learning analytics (LA) can raise concerns from students about their privacy in higher education contexts. Developing effective privacy-enhancing practices requires a systematic understanding of students' privacy concerns and how they vary across national and cultural dimensions. We conducted a survey study with established instruments to measure privacy concerns and cultural values for university students in five countries (Germany, South Korea, Spain, Sweden, and the United States; N = 762). The results show that students generally trusted institutions with their data and disclosed information as they perceived the risks to be manageable even though they felt somewhat limited in their ability to control their privacy. Across the five countries, German and Swedish students stood out as the most trusting and least concerned, especially compared to US students who reported greater perceived risk and less control. Students in South Korea and Spain responded similarly on all five privacy dimensions (perceived privacy risk, perceived privacy control, privacy concerns, trusting beliefs, and non-self-disclosure behavior), despite their significant cultural differences. Culture measured at the individual level affected the antecedents and outcomes of privacy concerns more than country-level culture. Perceived privacy risk and privacy control increase with power distance. Trusting beliefs increase with a desire for uncertainty avoidance and lower masculinity. Non-self-disclosure behaviors rise with power distance and masculinity, and decrease with more uncertainty avoidance. Thus, cultural values related to trust in institutions, social equality and risk-taking should be considered when developing privacy-enhancing practices and policies in higher education.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **How do students' privacy concerns in learning analytics vary across countries and cultures?** Specifically, the researchers hope to understand the privacy concerns of college students in different countries (Germany, South Korea, Spain, Sweden, and the United States) and the cultural factors behind them through surveys.
### Research Questions
1. **RQ1: How do students' privacy concerns in learning analytics change among different countries?**
- By comparing the views of students from five different countries on privacy issues in learning analytics, the researchers hope to reveal the specific differences in students' privacy concerns among various countries.
2. **RQ2: How does culture influence students' privacy concerns in learning analytics?**
- By introducing Hofstede's cultural dimension theory, the researchers explore the influence of cultural values (such as power distance, individualism/collectivism, masculinity/femininity, uncertainty avoidance) on students' privacy concerns.
### Research Background
- **Learning Analytics**: Although learning analytics technology has matured in the past decade, it still faces challenges in large - scale promotion in practical applications. One of the key issues is data privacy, which may hinder the successful implementation of learning analytics systems.
- **Privacy Concerns**: Privacy concerns refer to an individual's worry about the possible loss of privacy due to the leakage of personal information. These concerns not only affect students' trust in learning analytics systems but may also impede their wide application.
- **Cultural Differences**: There are significant differences in students' attitudes and expectations towards privacy in different countries and regions. Understanding these differences is crucial for formulating effective privacy protection measures.
### Methods
- **Sample Selection**: The researchers collected data from 762 students in universities in five different countries, covering different disciplines and degree levels.
- **Measurement Tools**: Use a validated questionnaire tool, including multiple sub - scales regarding privacy control perception, privacy risk perception, privacy concerns, trust beliefs, and non - self - disclosure behaviors.
### Main Findings
- **Trust and Concerns**: Overall, students have a relatively high level of trust in institutions, believing that privacy risks are controllable, but feel limited in their ability to control their own privacy.
- **National Differences**: Students in Germany and Sweden show the highest level of trust and the lowest privacy concerns, while American students show a higher perception of risk and a lower sense of control.
- **Cultural Influence**: Cultural dimensions (such as power distance, individualism/collectivism, masculinity/femininity, uncertainty avoidance) significantly influence students' privacy concerns. For example, in cultural backgrounds with high power distance and high masculinity, students have more non - self - disclosure behaviors; in cultural backgrounds with high uncertainty avoidance, students are more concerned about privacy risks.
Through this study, the author provides important empirical evidence for understanding students' privacy concerns in learning analytics across cultural backgrounds and provides a reference for formulating more effective privacy protection policies in the future.