Abstract:A few years ago it was shown that the superconformal index of the $\mathcal{N}=4$ supersymmetric $SU(N)$ Yang-Mills theory in the large $N$ limit matches with the entropy of $1/16$-supersymmetric black holes in type IIB string theory on $AdS_5\times S^5$. In some cases, an even more detailed match between the two sides is possible. When the two angular momentum chemical potentials in the index are equal, the superconformal index can be written as a discrete sum of Bethe ansatz solutions, and it was shown that specific terms in this sum are in a one-to-one correspondence to stable black hole solutions, and that the matching can be extended to non-perturbative contributions from wrapped D3-branes. A Bethe ansatz approach to computing the superconformal index exists also when the ratio of the angular momentum chemical potentials is any rational number, but in those cases it involves a sum over a very large number of terms (growing exponentially with $N$). Benini et al showed that a specific one of these terms matches with the black hole, but the role of the other terms is not clear. In this paper we analyze some of the additional contributions to the index in the Bethe ansatz approach, and we find that their matching to the gravity side is much more complicated than in the case of equal chemical potentials. In particular, we find some contributions that are larger than the one which was found to match the black holes, so that they must cancel with other large contributions. We give some evidence that cancellations of this type are possible, but we leave a full understanding of how they work to the future.

Large N expansion of superconformal index of k=1 ABJM theory and semiclassical M5 brane partition function

(2,0) theory on $S^5 \times S^1$ and quantum M2 branes

Non-planar corrections in ABJM theory from quantum M2 branes

Large $N$ Partition Functions of the ABJM Theory

Large N Schur index of = 4 SYM from semiclassical D3 brane

Instanton contributions to the ABJM free energy from quantum M2 branes

Giant graviton expansion of Schur index and quasimodular forms

Large $N$ Superconformal Indices for 3d Holographic SCFTs

Amplitudes for Multiple M5 Branes

Comments on ABJM free energy on $S^{3}$ at large $N$ and perturbative expansions in M-theory and string theory

Topologically twisted indices in five dimensions and holography

The superconformal index of N=1 class S fixed points

Large N expansion of mass deformed ABJM matrix model: M2-instanton condensation and beyond

Semiclassical quantization of M5 brane probes wrapped on $\textrm{AdS}_3\times S^3$ and defect anomalies

On the brane expansion of the Schur index

The Bethe Ansatz for the superconformal index with unequal angular momenta

Large $N$ Partition Functions of 3d Holographic SCFTs

Exact large $N$ expansion of mass deformed ABJM theory on squashed sphere

M5-brane sources, holography, and Argyres-Douglas theories