Evidence of an Off-resonant Electronic Transport Mechanism in Helicenes

T. de Ara,C. Hsu,A. Martinez-Garcia,B. C. Baciu,P. J. Bronk,L. Ornago,S. van der Poel,E. B. Lombardi,A. Guijarro,C. Sabater,C. Untiedt,H. S. J. van der Zant
2023-12-01
Abstract:Helical molecules have been identified as potential candidates for investigating electronic transport, spin filtering, or even piezoelectricity. However, the description of the transport mechanism is not straightforward in single molecular junctions. In this work, we study the electronic transport in break junctions of a series of three helical molecules: dithia[$n$]helicenes, with $n=7, 9, 11$ molecular units, and detail the synthesis of two kinds of dithia[11]helicenes, varying the location of the sulfur atoms. Our experimental study demonstrates low conductance values that remain similar across different biases and molecules. Additionally, we assess the length dependence of the conductance for each helicene, revealing an exponential decay characteristic of off-resonant transport. This behaviour is primarily attributed to the misalignment between the energy levels of the molecule-electrodes system. The length dependence trend described above is supported by \textit{ab initio} calculations, further confirming the off-resonant transport mechanism.
Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily discusses the characteristics of helicenes in electron transport mechanisms, particularly under non-resonant electron transport conditions. Researchers used the mechanically controllable break junction (MCBJ) technique to study the electronic transport properties of a series of helicenes at room temperature, including dithia[n]helicenes with different numbers of aromatic rings (n=7,9,11). The key findings of the paper are as follows: 1. **Low Conductance Values**: The experiments observed that helicenes exhibit low and similar conductance values under different bias voltages, indicating a misalignment of energy levels between the molecule and the electrode system. 2. **Length Dependence**: The study assessed the trend of conductance values for each helicene molecule as a function of molecular length and found an exponential decay, characteristic of non-resonant transport. This behavior is mainly due to the misalignment of energy levels in the molecule-electrode system. 3. **Theoretical Support**: Ab initio calculations further confirmed the non-resonant transport mechanism, showing the impact of different molecular configurations on electron transport. 4. **Influence of Sulfur Atom Position**: The study also explored the effects of two different positions of sulfur atoms in the helical structure, namely facing outward from the helical axis (exo) and facing inward (endo). The introduction of sulfur atoms aims to reduce potential barriers when the molecule bridges the electrodes while maintaining the conjugation of the entire molecule. 5. **Data Analysis Method**: To extract meaningful features from the recorded dataset, neural networks were used for classification to identify the breaking trajectories of the molecule bridging the electrodes. Subsequently, the K-means++ clustering algorithm was employed to separate molecular information, thereby revealing molecular characteristics. 6. **Statistical Analysis and Reproducibility**: Measurements were repeated under different bias voltages to check for variations in conductance and the reproducibility of results. Although the conductance values were not sensitive to changes in bias voltage, stability at high voltages posed a challenge for data collection. 7. **Non-Resonant Transport Mechanism**: The exponential decay trend of conductance with molecular length supports the hypothesis of a non-resonant transport mechanism, where electron transport occurs when the molecular energy levels do not match the electrode Fermi levels, resulting in lower conductance values. In summary, this research provides an in-depth understanding of the electronic transport properties of helicenes, especially their behavior under non-resonant conditions, which is significant for the development of molecular-based electronic devices. However, the low conductance values and misalignment of energy levels limit the ability to detect Circularly Polarized Light Induced Spin Selectivity (CISS) effects in these systems, suggesting the need for improved molecular design or the selection of different electrodes to enhance charge transport.