Mysteries of supercooled water elucidated by studies of aqueous solutions

Peter Lunkenheimer,Daniel Reuter,Arthur Schulz,Martin Wolf,Alois Loidl

2023-11-30

Abstract:The most abundant form of water in the universe probably is its supercooled state, staying non-crystalline down to lowest temperatures. The many peculiarities of liquid water, like its partly negative thermal expansion, have been traced back to prominent anomalies occurring in its supercooled form - especially under elevated pressure - and to the presence of two variants of supercooled water and of amorphous, glassy ice. However, the bare existence of these different liquid states and of a related liquid-liquid crossover at ambient pressure are controversially debated since decades, just as the absolute value of water's glass-transition temperature. Their direct experimental detection is hampered by the inevitable crystallization of pure water in a certain temperature range, termed "no-man's land". To tackle these problems, we have applied dielectric spectroscopy and differential scanning calorimetry to aqueous LiCl solutions. By covering a frequency range of up to 14 decades and by quenching some of the solutions to avoid crystallization, here we show that there are indeed strong hints at two forms of water, occurring in different temperature ranges and having different glass-transition temperatures, even at ambient pressure: A so-called "fragile" liquid, characterized by super-Arrhenius temperature dependence of the molecular dynamics at high temperatures, and a "strong" liquid, nearly following Arrhenius behaviour, at low temperatures.

Soft Condensed Matter,Disordered Systems and Neural Networks

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the existence and characteristics of two liquid forms of supercooled water and their fragile - to - strong transition (FST). Specifically, the research aims to experimentally verify the following issues:

1. **Two liquid forms of supercooled water**: Whether there are two forms of supercooled water in different temperature ranges, which have different glass - transition temperatures. One is called "fragile" liquid, which exhibits super - Arrhenius behavior at high temperatures; the other is "strong" liquid, which approaches Arrhenius behavior at low temperatures.

2. **Existence of fragile - to - strong transition (FST)**: Whether there really exists a phase change from fragile water to strong water. This transition is difficult to directly observe in pure water due to inevitable crystallization, especially in the so - called "no - man's land" (NML) temperature range (about 150 to 235 K).

3. **Exact value of glass - transition temperature (Tg)**: Determine the glass - transition temperature of water. This parameter is crucial for understanding the physical properties of water, but its absolute value has been controversial.

To overcome the inevitable crystallization problem of pure water in the NML temperature range, the researchers used LiCl aqueous solution for the experiment. Through broadband dielectric spectroscopy and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), they were able to avoid crystallization and study the molecular dynamics behavior in low - concentration LiCl solutions. These experiments revealed two key findings:

- At lower temperatures, there are indeed two different forms of water, and FST can be detected.
- By quenching low - concentration LiCl solutions, FST can be directly observed in the NML temperature range, which is a breakthrough that has not been achieved before.

In conclusion, this research provides strong evidence to support the existence of two liquid forms of supercooled water and the existence of fragile - to - strong transition, and provides a new perspective for further understanding the complex phase diagram of water.