Abstract:We explore the relationship between higher-form symmetries and entanglement properties in discrete lattice gauge theories, which can exhibit both topologically ordered phases and higher-form symmetry-protected topological (SPT) phases. Our study centers on generalizing the Fradkin-Shenker model, where the Gauss law constraint can be either emergent or exact. The phase diagram includes a topologically ordered phase and a non-trivial SPT phase protected by a 1-form and a 0-form symmetry. We obtain the following key findings: First, the entanglement properties depend on whether the 1-form symmetries and the Gauss law are exact or emergent. For the emergent Gauss law, the entanglement spectrum (ES) of the non-trivial SPT phase exhibits degeneracies, which are robust at low energies against weak perturbations that explicitly break the exact 1-form symmetry. When the Gauss law and the 1-form symmetry are both exact, the ES degeneracy is extensive. This extensive degeneracy is fragile and can be removed completely by infinitesimal perturbations that explicitly break the exact 1-form symmetry while keeping the Gauss law exact. Second, we consider the ES in the topologically ordered phase where 1-form symmetries are spontaneously broken. In contrast to the ES of the non-trivial SPT phase, we find that spontaneous higher-form symmetry breaking removes "half" of the ES levels, leading to a non-degenerate ES in the topologically ordered phase in general. Third, we derive a connection between spontaneous higher-form symmetry breaking and the topological entanglement entropy (TEE). Using this relation, we investigate the entanglement entropy that can be distilled in the deconfined phase of the original Fradkin-Shenker model using gauge-invariant measurements. We show that the TEE is robust against the measurement when the 1-form symmetry is emergent but fragile when the 1-form symmetry is exact.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the relationship between higher - form symmetries and entanglement properties in lattice gauge theories with discrete gauge groups. Specifically, the author explores how higher - form symmetries affect the entanglement spectrum (ES) and topological entanglement entropy (TEE) of the system in lattice gauge theories with discrete gauge groups, especially in topologically ordered phases and symmetry - protected topological phases (SPT phases) protected by higher - form symmetries. By studying a generalized Fradkin - Shenker model, the paper investigates how the entanglement properties of the system differ when the Gauss's law constraint and 1 - form symmetry are exact or emergent.
### Main research questions:
1. **Relationship between higher - form symmetries and entanglement spectrum**: Study how the entanglement spectrum of the system changes under different conditions (such as when the Gauss's law constraint and 1 - form symmetry are exact or emergent).
2. **Entanglement properties in topologically ordered phases and SPT phases**: Explore how the spontaneous breaking of higher - form symmetries affects the entanglement spectrum and topological entanglement entropy in these phases.
3. **Effect of Gauss's law constraint on entanglement properties**: Analyze how the entanglement properties of the system differ when the Gauss's law constraint is exact or emergent.
4. **Robustness of higher - form symmetries**: Study the stability of higher - form symmetries when perturbed, especially the emergent properties of these symmetries at low energies.
### Research background:
- **Higher - form symmetries**: Usual 0 - form symmetries act on the entire system, while higher - form symmetries are related to low - dimensional sub - manifolds. These symmetries can protect nontrivial SPT phases and, in some cases, can be spontaneously broken, leading to new matter phases.
- **Entanglement properties**: The entanglement spectrum and topological entanglement entropy are important tools for characterizing the topological properties of quantum many - body systems. In particular, the topological entanglement entropy can be used to diagnose topologically ordered phases.
### Research methods:
- **Generalized Fradkin - Shenker model**: This model allows terms that violate the Gauss's law constraint to be included, so that the entanglement properties of the system can be studied in different parameter regions.
- **Numerical simulation**: Use two - dimensional tensor network states (2D tensor network states) to variationally or perturbatively find the ground state and efficiently extract its entanglement properties.
### Main findings:
1. **Degeneracy of the entanglement spectrum**:
- When both the 1 - form Wilson loop symmetry and the Gauss's law constraint are exact, the entanglement spectrum exhibits extensive \(2^N\) - fold degeneracy.
- When the 1 - form Wilson loop symmetry is exact and the Gauss's law constraint is emergent, the extensive degeneracy of the entanglement spectrum is completely lifted.
- When the 1 - form Wilson loop symmetry is emergent and the Gauss's law constraint is exact, the degeneracy of the entanglement spectrum is reduced from \(2^N\) - fold to 2 - fold.
- When both the 1 - form Wilson loop symmetry and the Gauss's law constraint are emergent, the 2 - fold degeneracy is robust against perturbations at low energies.
2. **Entanglement Hamiltonian in topologically ordered phases**:
- In topologically ordered phases, the entanglement Hamiltonian contains a non - local projection operator, which will lead to general non - degeneracy of the entanglement spectrum.
3. **Topological entanglement entropy**:
- The topological entanglement entropy exhibits an area law minus the topological entanglement entropy in the deconfined phase.
- When the 1 - form 't Hooft loop symmetry is exact, the topological entanglement entropy disappears; when the 1 - form 't Hooft loop symmetry is emergent, the topological entanglement entropy exists.
### Conclusion:
This paper reveals the important role of higher - form symmetries in understanding the entanglement properties of lattice gauge theories by studying the generalized Fradkin - Shenker model. The research results show that the exactness and emergence of higher - form symmetries have a significant impact on the entanglement spectrum and topological entanglement entropy of the system, providing a new perspective for understanding topologically ordered phases and SPT phases.