Wannier charge center, spin resolved bulk polarization and corner modes in a strained quantum spin Hall insulator

Srijata Lahiri,Saurabh Basu

2023-11-28

Abstract:Topological invariants are a significant ingredient in the study of topological phases of matter that intertwines the supposedly contradicting concepts of bulk and boundary. The nature of the invariants differ depending on the dimension of the boundary at which the topological states manifest themselves. The primary motivation of this work is to study two distinct scenarios of topological phase, differing in the dimensionality of their boundary states and study the associated bulk topological invariants that characterize them. In this regard, we study the band engineered Kane Mele model which originally is a prototypical example of a system that hosts quantum spin Hall effect on a honeycomb lattice. Under a smooth band deformation caused by varying one of the nearest neighbor hopping amplitudes (say $t_1$) as compared to the other two (say $t$), we observe that the system transits from its first order topological insulating state (or quantum spin Hall state) to a second order topological insulating (SOTI) state via a gap closing transition. This transition occurs when the system crosses a particular threshold of the deformation parameter $t_1\mathbin{/}t$ (namely $t_1\mathbin{/}t=2$). We show the presence of edge and corner modes as a signature of first and second order topology respectively. Further, we observe the evolution of the Wannier charge center (WCC), a bulk property as a function of the deformation parameter ${t_1}\mathbin{/}{t}$. We also find that, while the $\mathbb{Z}_2$ invariant successfully characterizes the QSH state, it cannot characterize higher order topology (second order here). The model being mirror invariant, we also calculate mirror winding number to show that it is rendered trivial in the SOTI phase as well, while being non-trivial in the QSH phase. Finally, spin resolved bulk polarization establishes the SOTI phase as obstructed atomic insulator.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to study the transition of quantum spin - Hall insulators from the first - order topological phase to the second - order topological phase under band - structure deformation, as well as the differences between these topological phases of different orders. Specifically:

1. **Research Background**:
- Quantum Spin Hall Insulator (QSH) is a special type of material. They have an energy gap in the bulk state but gapless edge states on the boundary.
- By changing the ratio $\xi=\frac{t_1}{t}$ of the nearest - neighbor hopping amplitude $t_1$ to the other two nearest - neighbor hopping amplitudes $t$, a smooth deformation of the band structure can be achieved.

2. **Research Objectives**:
- To study the transition from the quantum spin - Hall phase (QSH) to the second - order topological insulator (SOTI) in the Kane - Mele model during the band - structure deformation process.
- To analyze and characterize these two topological phases of different orders and their corresponding bulk topological invariants.

3. **Main Findings**:
- When $\xi < 2$, the system is in the quantum spin - Hall phase and has obvious helical edge states.
- When $\xi = 2$, the system undergoes a phase - transition point with a closed energy gap, the so - called semi - Dirac limit.
- When $\xi> 2$, the system enters the second - order topological insulator phase, the edge states disappear, and zero - energy corner modes appearing at the two corners of the supercell are instead.
- By analyzing bulk properties such as hybridized Wannier charge centers (WCC), mirror winding numbers, and spin - resolved bulk polarizations, the characteristics of these two topological phases of different orders are revealed.

4. **Conclusions**:
- Through the smooth deformation of the band structure, the transition from the first - order topological phase to the second - order topological phase can be achieved.
- The Z2 invariant is non - trivial in the QSH phase and becomes trivial in the SOTI phase.
- The mirror winding number is only non - trivial in the QSH phase.
- Spin - resolved bulk polarization shows that in the SOTI phase, the charge center deviates from the actual lattice point, resulting in fractional charge accumulation at the two corners of the supercell, thus exhibiting second - order topological characteristics.

Through these studies, the authors not only revealed the differences between topological phases of different orders but also provided a new perspective for understanding high - order topological insulators.