The Steward Observatory LEO Satellite Photometric Survey

Harrison Krantz,Eric C. Pearce,Adam Block

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1538-3873/acf40c

2023-11-24

Abstract:The Steward Observatory LEO Satellite Photometric Survey is a comprehensive observational survey to characterize the apparent brightness of the Starlink and OneWeb low Earth orbit satellites and evaluate the potential impact on astronomy. We report the results of over 16,000 independent measurements of nearly 2800 individual satellites. In addition to photometry, we also measured the astrometric position of each satellite and evaluated the accuracy of predicting satellite position with the available two-line element sets. The apparent brightness of a satellite seen in the sky is not constant and depends on the Sun-satellite-observer geometry. To capture this, we designed the survey to create an all-geometries set of measurements to fully characterize the brightness of each population of satellites as seen in the sky. We visualize the data with sky-plots that show the correlation of apparent brightness with on-sky position and relative Sun-satellite-observer geometry. The sky-plots show where in the sky the satellites are brightest. In addition to visual magnitudes, we also present two new metrics: the expected photon flux and the effective albedo. The expected photon flux metric assesses the potential impact on astronomy sensors by predicting the flux for a satellite trail in an image from a theoretical 1 m class telescope and sensor. The effective albedo metric assesses where a satellite is more reflective than baseline, which ties to the physical structure of the satellite and indicates the potential for brightness-reducing design changes. We intend to use this methodology and resulting data to inform the astronomy community about satellite brightness.

Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate the potential impacts of Low - Earth - Orbit (LEO) satellites, especially the Starlink and OneWeb satellite constellations, on astronomical observations. With the rapid increase in the number of these satellites, their brightness in the night sky and their impacts on astronomical observations are becoming more and more significant. Specifically, the study aims to:

1. **Measure and characterize the apparent brightness of satellites**: Through comprehensive photometry, determine the variation in the apparent brightness of these satellites under different Sun - satellite - observer geometric conditions.
2. **Evaluate the accuracy of satellite position prediction**: Measure the astrometric positions of satellites and evaluate the accuracy of predicting satellite positions using the existing Two - Line Element Sets (TLE).
3. **Provide new evaluation metrics**: Introduce two new evaluation metrics - expected photon flux and effective albedo - to more accurately assess the impact of satellites on astronomical observations.
4. **Provide data support for the astronomical community**: Through systematic measurement and data analysis, help astronomers understand the brightness distribution of satellites, thereby evaluating their impact on observation projects and possibly taking measures to avoid the most severe impacts.

### Key issues

- **Variability of satellite brightness**: The apparent brightness of a satellite is not constant but depends on the geometric relationship between the Sun, the satellite, and the observer. Therefore, comprehensive measurements are required to capture this variation.
- **Impact of satellites on astronomical observations**: The appearance of satellites may cause trailing phenomena in images, interfere with the observation of target celestial bodies, and even damage data. Especially at dusk, when the satellite brightness is higher, the impact is more obvious.
- **Future growth in the number of satellites**: It is expected that the number of LEO satellites will reach tens of thousands in the future, which will further intensify the challenges to astronomical observations.

### Method overview

To achieve the above - mentioned goals, the researchers designed and implemented the Steward Observatory LEO Satellite Photometric Survey. This survey uses an automated observation system to perform photometry and astrometry on satellites, recording more than 16,000 independent measurement results involving nearly 2,800 individual satellites. In this way, the researchers can comprehensively characterize the brightness variation of these satellites in the night sky and provide valuable data support for the astronomical community.

### New evaluation metrics

1. **Expected photon flux**: Evaluate the potential impact of satellite trajectories on astronomical sensors in images and predict the photon flux received by a theoretical 1 - meter - class telescope and sensor.
2. **Effective albedo**: Evaluate the reflection characteristics of satellites relative to the baseline reflectivity, indicating the physical properties of satellite structures and their design potential for reducing brightness.

Through these efforts, the researchers hope to provide a scientific basis for the astronomical community to help them better understand and deal with the impact of LEO satellites on astronomical observations.