What Lies beyond the Pareto Front? A Survey on Decision-Support Methods for Multi-Objective Optimization

Zuzanna Osika,Jazmin Zatarain Salazar,Diederik M. Roijers,Frans A. Oliehoek,Pradeep K. Murukannaiah
2023-11-19
Abstract:We present a review that unifies decision-support methods for exploring the solutions produced by multi-objective optimization (MOO) algorithms. As MOO is applied to solve diverse problems, approaches for analyzing the trade-offs offered by MOO algorithms are scattered across fields. We provide an overview of the advances on this topic, including methods for visualization, mining the solution set, and uncertainty exploration as well as emerging research directions, including interactivity, explainability, and ethics. We synthesize these methods drawing from different fields of research to build a unified approach, independent of the application. Our goals are to reduce the entry barrier for researchers and practitioners on using MOO algorithms and to provide novel research directions.
Artificial Intelligence
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to solve the problem of synthesizing and unifying decision - support methods for solution sets generated by multi - objective optimization (MOO) algorithms. Specifically, the paper focuses on how to effectively analyze the non - dominated solution sets (i.e., Pareto - optimal sets) generated by MOO algorithms, especially when these solution sets are very large or contain uncertainties, and how to help decision - makers (DMs) understand and select the final solution. The paper points out that as the number of objectives increases, the size of the solution sets generated by MOO algorithms will also increase accordingly, which makes the analysis of these solution sets very complicated. Therefore, effective decision - support methods are needed to help DMs systematically explore alternative solutions to determine the final solution. The paper mainly solves this problem in the following ways: 1. **Visualization**: The paper discusses various visualization techniques for exploring MOO solution sets, such as parallel coordinate plots (PCPs), pair - wise scatter plots, heat maps, and radar charts. These tools can help DMs intuitively understand the various solutions in the solution sets and the relationships between them. 2. **Solution - set mining**: In addition to visualization, the paper also introduces data - mining methods, including supervised and unsupervised learning methods, for extracting valuable information from solution sets. For example, through cluster analysis, different solution - set clusters can be discovered in the objective space, and more detailed insights can be provided within each cluster through association - rule mining. 3. **Uncertainty exploration**: The paper explores methods for dealing with stochastic uncertainty and deep uncertainty in the MOO process. These methods aim to help DMs understand the impact of different parameter combinations on the results, especially in long - term planning, where these uncertainties may have a significant impact on decision - making. In addition, the paper also proposes several emerging research directions, including interactive visualization, enhanced interpretability, and ethical support, which aim to further improve the practicality and effectiveness of decision - support systems. Through these methods, the paper hopes to lower the threshold for researchers and practitioners to use MOO algorithms and provide new directions for future MOO research.