A Systems-Theoretical Formalization of Closed Systems

Niloofar Shadab,Tyler Cody,Alejandro Salado,Peter Beling
2023-11-17
Abstract:There is a lack of formalism for some key foundational concepts in systems engineering. One of the most recently acknowledged deficits is the inadequacy of systems engineering practices for engineering intelligent systems. In our previous works, we proposed that closed systems precepts could be used to accomplish a required paradigm shift for the systems engineering of intelligent systems. However, to enable such a shift, formal foundations for closed systems precepts that expand the theory of systems engineering are needed. The concept of closure is a critical concept in the formalism underlying closed systems precepts. In this paper, we provide formal, systems- and information-theoretic definitions of closure to identify and distinguish different types of closed systems. Then, we assert a mathematical framework to evaluate the subjective formation of the boundaries and constraints of such systems. Finally, we argue that engineering an intelligent system can benefit from appropriate closed and open systems paradigms on multiple levels of abstraction of the system. In the main, this framework will provide the necessary fundamentals to aid in systems engineering of intelligent systems.
Artificial Intelligence,Systems and Control
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve The paper aims to address the lack of formal foundational theories in systems engineering, particularly when dealing with intelligent systems. Specifically, the authors believe that current systems engineering practices are inadequate for handling artificial intelligence (AI) systems because the high coupling of these systems with their environments renders traditional systems engineering methods unsuitable. To solve this problem, the authors propose a formal framework based on the principle of closed systems to better understand and design intelligent systems. ### Main Content 1. **Background Introduction**: - The field of systems engineering has long called for a theoretical foundation to establish an independent engineering discipline capable of addressing modern engineering problems. - With the emergence of complex systems, especially the rise of AI systems, traditional systems engineering methods face challenges. - In previous research, the authors pointed out that intelligence is a relational attribute that can be characterized and engineered through the relationship between a system and its environment. 2. **Revisiting the Concept of Closed Systems**: - The concept of closed systems has limited application in systems engineering and lacks a theoretical foundation. - The authors propose the concepts of functional closure and informational closure and provide formal definitions. - Functional closure refers to the system's behavior and output being unaffected by external inputs, while informational closure means there is no new information exchange between the system and its environment. 3. **Formal Definitions**: - Using the foundations of information theory and systems theory, the authors define functional closure and informational closure. - Functional closure is described through mathematically defined functional dependency relationships, ensuring that the system's output depends only on a minimal set of inputs. - Informational closure is described through the concepts of information entropy and mutual information, ensuring zero information exchange between the system and its environment. 4. **Applications and Significance**: - Through these formal definitions, the authors hope to provide systems engineers with a tool to better understand and apply the principles of closed systems when designing intelligent systems. - This formal framework can help systems engineers evaluate and design intelligent systems at multiple levels of abstraction, thereby improving system reliability and efficiency. ### Conclusion By revisiting the concept of closed systems and proposing formal definitions of functional closure and informational closure, the paper provides a new theoretical foundation for the field of systems engineering. This not only helps address the current inadequacies in handling intelligent systems but also offers new ideas and methods for future system design.