An Observer's Measure of De Sitter Entropy

Mehrdad Mirbabayi
2023-11-24
Abstract:The two-point correlation function of a massive field $\langle \chi(\tau)\chi(0)\rangle$, measured along an observer's worldline in de Sitter (dS), decays exponentially as $\tau \to \infty$. Meanwhile, every dS observer is surrounded by a horizon and the holographic interpretation of the horizon entropy $S_{\rm dS}$ suggests that the correlation function should stop decaying, and start behaving erratically at late times. We find evidence for this expectation in Jackiw-Teitelboim gravity by finding a topologically nontrivial saddle, which is suppressed by $e^{-S_{\rm dS}}$, and which gives a constant contribution to $|\langle \chi(\tau)\chi(0)\rangle|^2$. This constant might have the interpretation of the late-time average of $|\langle \chi(\tau)\chi(0)\rangle|^2$ over all microscopic theories that have the same low-energy effective description.
High Energy Physics - Theory,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the behavior of the two - point correlation function of the matter field on a long - time scale in de Sitter (dS) space. Specifically, the paper explores that the correlation function predicted by the Effective Field Theory (EFT) will decay exponentially indefinitely on a long - time scale, which is in contradiction with the Holographic Principle. The Holographic Principle implies that after a certain point in time, the correlation function should stop decaying and start to exhibit random behavior. The goal of the paper is to find evidence of the failure of the Effective Field Theory to support the expectations of the Holographic Principle. ### Background and Motivation 1. **Correlation functions in quantum systems**: - In a quantum system in a finite - dimensional Hilbert space, the correlation function cannot decay forever. In the energy basis, each correlation function can be expressed as an expansion form of pure oscillating phases: \[ \langle \chi(t)\chi(0) \rangle = \sum_{ij} a_{ij} e^{-i(E_i - E_j)t} \] - Within a short enough time, the interactions between different energy levels can simulate the overall decay behavior, but this collective behavior will eventually stop, especially when \( t > \frac{1}{\Delta E} \), where \(\Delta E\) is the typical spacing between energy levels. 2. **Horizon entropy in de Sitter space**: - In an expanding spacetime, there is a horizon around the observer. In the exact de Sitter space, Gibbons and Hawking defined the horizon entropy \( S_{\text{dS}} \) as \( S_{\text{dS}}=\frac{A}{4G_N} \), where \( A \) is the area of the horizon and \( G_N \) is the Newtonian gravitational constant. - Applying the Holographic Principle to the de Sitter horizon means that there is a dual description, that is, a quantum system with a Hilbert space of dimension \( e^{S_{\text{dS}}} \). If so, the correlation function measured along the observer's world line cannot decay indefinitely. However, the Effective Field Theory predicts such an indefinite exponential decay. 3. **The contradiction between the Effective Field Theory and the Holographic Principle**: - This contradiction is similar to Hawking's information - loss paradox, and there are similar problems for asymptotically anti - de Sitter (AdS) black holes, which were initially pointed out by Maldacena. - The de Sitter version and its consequences on an exponentially long - time scale (\( t\sim e^{S_{\text{dS}}} \)) have been emphasized in the literature. For example, there is an \( O(1) \) probability that, in a vacuum landscape, a given observer will tunnel out of any expanding vacuum before the Poincaré recurrence time. ### Main contributions of the paper 1. **Evidence in Jackiw - Teitelboim gravity**: - The paper found a topologically non - trivial saddle point in Jackiw - Teitelboim gravity, which is suppressed by \( e^{-S_{\text{dS}}} \) and has a constant contribution to \( |\langle \chi(\tau)\chi(0) \rangle|^2 \). - This constant can be interpreted as the average value of \( |\langle \chi(\tau)\chi(0) \rangle|^2 \) on a long - time scale in all microscopic theories with the same low - energy effective description. 2. **The observer's dynamic clock**: - The paper introduced a dynamic clock variable to partially localize the fields on the world line. By introducing a pair of conjugate variables \((p, q)\) and adding the corresponding terms in the path integral, these fields can be fully localized. - The introduction of the dynamic clock is very important conceptually because it allows the rest mass \( M + q \) of the observer to change when the operator is inserted while maintaining the total energy - momentum conservation. 3. **Matter correlation functions in double - horn geometry**: