Hydrodynamic theories for a system of weakly self-interacting classical ultra-relativistic scalar particles: causality and stability

Caio V. P. de Brito,Gabriel S. Rocha,Gabriel S. Denicol

2023-11-13

Abstract:We investigate the causality and stability of three different relativistic dissipative fluid-dynamical formulations emerging from a system of classical, ultra-relativistic scalar particles self-interacting via a quartic potential. For this particular interaction, all transport coefficients of Navier-Stokes, Bemfica-Disconzi-Noronha-Kovtun and second-order transient theories can be computed in analytical form. We first show that Navier-Stokes theory is acausal and unstable regardless of the matching conditions. On the other hand, BDNK theory can be linearly causal and stable for a particular set of matching choices that does not contain the so-called exotic Eckart prescription. In particular, using the Liénard-Chipart criterion, we obtain a set of sufficient conditions that guarantee the stability of the theory. Last, second-order transient hydrodynamic theory in Landau matching is shown to be linearly causal and stable.

Nuclear Theory,High Energy Physics - Theory

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to explore the causality and stability of three different relativistic dissipative hydrodynamics theories in describing the classical ultra - relativistic scalar particle system (these particles self - interact through a quartic potential). Specifically, these three theories are:

1. **Navier - Stokes theory**: It was found that, regardless of the matching conditions, the Navier - Stokes theory is non - causal and unstable.
2. **Bemfica - Disconzi - Noronha - Kovtun (BDNK) theory**: It was found that under specific matching conditions, the BDNK theory can be linearly causal and stable. In particular, using the Liénard - Chipart criterion, sufficient conditions for ensuring the stability of the theory can be obtained.
3. **Second - order transient hydrodynamics theory**: Under the Landau matching condition, this theory is proven to be linearly causal and stable.

### Main problems
The main problems that the paper attempts to solve are:
- **Causality**: Ensure that the propagation speed of signals in the fluid does not exceed the speed of light.
- **Linear stability**: Ensure that perturbations around the global equilibrium state will decay over time.

### Methods
The paper evaluates the causality and linear stability of these theories by analyzing small perturbations. The specific steps include:
1. **Linearize the hydrodynamic equations**: Consider small perturbations of all hydrodynamic fields and linearize them.
2. **Fourier transform**: Transform the linearized equations into Fourier space for easier analysis.
3. **Solve the dispersion relation**: Determine the causality and stability of the system by solving the dispersion relation.

### Results
- **Navier - Stokes theory**: Regardless of the matching conditions, this theory is non - causal and unstable.
- **BDNK theory**: Under specific matching conditions, this theory can be linearly causal and stable. In particular, when \( z > 1 \), the theory is stable.
- **Second - order transient hydrodynamics theory**: Under the Landau matching condition, this theory is linearly causal and stable.

### Conclusions
Through detailed analysis, the paper proves the deficiencies of the Navier - Stokes theory in describing relativistic fluids and shows the advantages of the BDNK theory and the second - order transient hydrodynamics theory under specific conditions. These results are of great significance for understanding the causality and stability of relativistic hydrodynamics.