Quantum-to-classical crossover in the spin glass dynamics of cavity QED simulators

Hossein Hosseinabadi,Darrick E. Chang,Jamir Marino

2024-06-07

Abstract:By solving the quench dynamics of a frustrated many-body spin-boson problem, we investigate the role of spin size on the dynamical formation of spin glass order. In particular, we observe that quantum and classical spin glasses exhibit markedly different evolution. The former displays a quick relaxation of magnetization together with an exponential dependence of the spin glass order parameter on spin size, while the latter has long-lasting prethermal magnetization and a spin glass order parameter independent of spin size. The quantum-to-classical crossover is sharp and occurs for relatively small spins, highlighting the fragility of the quantum regime. Furthermore, we show that spin glass order is resonantly enhanced when the frequency of the bosonic mediators of the interactions approaches the value of the transverse field. Our predictions are relevant for all spin glass systems with $SU(2)$ degrees of freedom away from equilibrium, and can be examined in recently developed multi-mode cavity QED experiments.

Disordered Systems and Neural Networks,Statistical Mechanics,Quantum Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the dynamic conversion mechanism between quantum spin glass (QSG) and classical spin glass (CSG). Specifically, by solving the quenching dynamics of a frustrated many - body spin - boson problem, the author studied the influence of spin size on the dynamic formation of spin - glass order. The core problems of the paper are:

1. **Dynamic differences between quantum and classical spin glasses**:
- Quantum spin glass exhibits rapid magnetization relaxation and an exponential dependence of the spin - glass order parameter on spin size.
- Classical spin glass shows long - time pre - heating magnetization and the independence of the spin - glass order parameter on spin size.

2. **Quantum - to - classical crossover point**:
- The quantum - to - classical crossover point is sharp and occurs at a relatively small spin size, indicating the fragility of the quantum state.
- By adjusting the spin size \( S \), the transition between the quantum and classical behaviors of the system can be controlled.

3. **Effect of photon frequency on spin - glass order**:
- When the frequency of the photon is close to the value of the transverse field, the spin - glass order is resonantly enhanced.
- This phenomenon is due to the enhancement of photon - mediated interactions under resonant conditions, while the generation of incoherent photons leads to heating, thereby weakening the spin - glass order.

4. **Experimental verification**:
- The predictions of the paper are applicable to all spin - glass systems with SU(2) degrees of freedom and far from equilibrium.
- These predictions can be verified in the recently developed multimode cavity quantum electrodynamics (cavity QED) experiments.

### Formula summary

- **Hamiltonian**:
\[
H=\frac{\Delta}{2} \sum_{i,\lambda} \sigma_z^{i\lambda}+\omega \sum_{\alpha} a^{\dagger}_{\alpha} a_{\alpha}+\sum_{i,\lambda,\alpha} g_{\alpha i}\left(a_{\alpha}+a^{\dagger}_{\alpha}\right) \sigma_x^{i\lambda}
\]

- **Dissipative term**:
\[
D[a_{\alpha}] \rho=\frac{\kappa}{2}\left(a_{\alpha} \rho a^{\dagger}_{\alpha}-\left\{a^{\dagger}_{\alpha} a_{\alpha}, \rho\right\}\right)
\]

- **Spin - glass order parameter**:
\[
q_{\text{EA}}(\tau)=\lim_{t \to \infty} C(\tau, \tau - t)=\lim_{t \to \infty} \frac{1}{N_s^2}\langle\{S_x^i(\tau), S_x^i(\tau - t)\}\rangle
\]

- **Change of spin - glass order parameter with spin size**:
\[
q_{\text{EA}} = q_c - r_q e^{-A S}
\]
where \( q_c \) is the classical value, \( r_q \) is the magnitude of quantum correction, and \( A \) is the attenuation constant.

### Conclusion

Through theoretical analysis and numerical simulation, the paper reveals the significant differences in the dynamic behaviors between quantum spin glass and classical spin glass, and points out the sharpness of the quantum - to - classical crossover point. These findings not only deepen the understanding of quantum and classical spin glasses but also provide specific predictions for experimental verification.