Which black hole is spinning? Probing the origin of black-hole spin with gravitational waves

Christian Adamcewicz,Shanika Galaudage,Paul D. Lasky,Eric Thrane
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3847/2041-8213/ad2df2
2024-02-26
Abstract:Theoretical studies of angular momentum transport suggest that isolated stellar-mass black holes are born with negligible dimensionless spin magnitudes $\chi \lesssim 0.01$. However, recent gravitational-wave observations indicate $\gtrsim 40\%$ of binary black hole systems contain at least one black hole with a non-negligible spin magnitude. One explanation is that the first-born black hole spins up the stellar core of what will become the second-born black hole through tidal interactions. Typically, the second-born black hole is the ``secondary'' (less-massive) black hole, though, it may become the ``primary'' (more-massive) black hole through a process known as mass-ratio reversal. We investigate this hypothesis by analysing data from the third gravitational-wave transient catalog (GWTC-3) using a ``single-spin'' framework in which only one black hole may spin in any given binary. Given this assumption, we show that at least $28\%$ (90% credibility) of the LIGO--Virgo--KAGRA binaries contain a primary with significant spin, possibly indicative of mass-ratio reversal. We find no evidence for binaries that contain a secondary with significant spin. However, the single-spin framework is moderately disfavoured (natural log Bayes factor $\ln B = 3.1$) when compared to a model that allows both black holes to spin. If future studies can firmly establish that most merging binaries contain two spinning black holes, it may call into question our understanding of formation mechanisms for binary black holes or the efficiency of angular momentum transport in black hole progenitors.
High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily explores the issue of black hole spin, particularly investigating the spin characteristics of black holes at their origin through gravitational wave observations. The core research questions can be summarized as follows: 1. **Background and Challenges**: Theoretical studies suggest that isolated stellar-mass black holes should have very small dimensionless spin parameters at formation (\(\chi \lesssim 0.01\)). However, recent gravitational wave observations show that over 40% of binary black hole systems contain at least one black hole with non-zero spin. 2. **Explanations and Hypotheses**: A popular explanation is that the first-formed black hole (referred to as the "primary black hole") can induce the core of the star that will become the second black hole to spin through tidal interactions. Typically, the second-formed black hole is the less massive one (secondary black hole), but in some cases, it may become the more massive black hole (primary black hole) due to mass reversal. 3. **Research Objectives**: This paper aims to test the above hypothesis by analyzing data from the third catalog of gravitational wave transient events (GWTC-3) using the so-called "single-spin framework" (where only one black hole in each binary black hole system is allowed to spin). The researchers seek to determine the proportion of binary black hole systems that contain a significantly spinning primary black hole, which may be a result of mass reversal. 4. **Main Findings**: - At least 28% (90% confidence level) of LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA binary black hole systems contain a significantly spinning primary black hole. - There is no evidence for significantly spinning secondary black holes. - The single-spin framework is slightly less supported compared to models allowing both black holes to spin (natural logarithm Bayes factor \(ln B = 3.1\)). - If future research confirms that most merging binary black hole systems contain two spinning black holes, it may challenge our understanding of the formation mechanisms of binary black hole systems or the efficiency of angular momentum transfer in their progenitor stars. In summary, this paper focuses on exploring the origin of black hole spins in binary black hole systems using gravitational wave data and provides new insights into the spin characteristics of these systems through statistical analysis.