Electric or gasoline: a simple model to decide when buying a new vehicle

René Ledesma-Alonso,Guillermo Becerra-Nuñez

2024-01-24

Abstract:In this work, a simple methodology to follow the behavior of motorized urban vehicles, from the point of view of personal finances, is presented. Including the acquisition of a new vehicle, the analysis considers the driving distance per week, the average speed, the time spent at rest due to traffic conditions, the evolution of gasoline and electric energy prices, maintenance and services, and local taxes. Herein, two low-range compact vehicles were chosen and compared: one powered by combustion of gasoline, and the other by electric energy stored in batteries. Historical data and trend projections, according to inflation and prices evolution, are taken into consideration. The developed model may help to select adequately a new vehicle, according to the user's needs. A good choice depends strongly on the usage and traffic conditions, the electric vehicle being suitable for large weekly driving distances and heavy traffic, whereas the gasoline vehicle is preferred for short distances and light traffic. The expenses of the vehicles are compared through time, with different scenarios envisaged according to the user's resolution to keep the vehicle for the entire lifespan or to sell it quickly.

Fluid Dynamics,Physics and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve

This paper aims to assist individuals in making economic decisions when purchasing a new car through a simple model. Specifically, the model considers the following aspects:

1. **Driving Distance**: Weekly driving distance.
2. **Average Speed**: The average speed of the vehicle.
3. **Traffic Conditions**: Idle time due to traffic congestion.
4. **Energy Prices**: Trends in gasoline and electricity prices.
5. **Maintenance and Service Costs**: Costs of vehicle maintenance and service.
6. **Local Taxes**: Various taxes related to the vehicle.

The paper compares two types of low-end compact cars: one powered by gasoline and the other by electricity stored in batteries. By using historical data and price trend forecasts, the model helps users choose the appropriate vehicle based on their needs. The model's results show that electric vehicles are suitable for long weekly driving distances and severe traffic congestion, while gasoline vehicles are more suitable for short distances and light traffic conditions.

### Main Research Content

1. **Motion Characteristics and Vehicle Performance**:
- Introduces how to measure and calculate the vehicle's driving distance, average speed, and idle time.
- Analyzes the vehicle's range, including the fuel tank capacity and fuel consumption rate of gasoline cars, and the battery capacity and energy consumption rate of electric cars.

2. **Energy Consumption and Prices**:
- Describes the trends in gasoline and electricity prices and provides corresponding mathematical models.
- Calculates the weekly gasoline and electricity consumption and their related costs.

3. **Economic Considerations**:
- **Depreciation**: The depreciation of the vehicle, including initial value and changes over time.
- **Consumer Price Index (CPI)**: Monthly inflation rate and its impact on costs.
- **Maintenance and Technical Service**: Costs of regular maintenance and technical services and their changes over time.
- **Taxes**: Including vehicle emission control tax, public road tax, and ownership tax.

4. **Total Costs**:
- Proposes two schemes to compare the total costs of gasoline cars and electric cars:
- Scheme 1: The owner holds the vehicle for its entire lifecycle.
- Scheme 2: The owner sells the vehicle after a certain period, recovering part of the value.

### Results

By analyzing a specific case in Mexico City, the paper demonstrates the cost variations under different driving distances. The results show that electric vehicles have an economic advantage in long-distance driving and traffic congestion, while gasoline vehicles are more economical in short distances and light traffic conditions. These results help users make more reasonable car purchase decisions based on their usage conditions and traffic situations.