Incorporating temporal dynamics of mutations to enhance the prediction capability of antiretroviral therapy's outcome for HIV-1

Giulia Di Teodoro,Martin Pirkl,Francesca Incardona,Ilaria Vicenti,Anders Sönnerborg,Rolf Kaiser,Laura Palagi,Maurizio Zazzi,Thomas Lengauer
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/bioinformatics/btae327
2024-06-24
Abstract:Motivation: In predicting HIV therapy outcomes, a critical clinical question is whether using historical information can enhance predictive capabilities compared with current or latest available data analysis. This study analyses whether historical knowledge, which includes viral mutations detected in all genotypic tests before therapy, their temporal occurrence, and concomitant viral load measurements, can bring improvements. We introduce a method to weigh mutations, considering the previously enumerated factors and the reference mutation-drug Stanford resistance tables. We compare a model encompassing history (H) with one not using it (NH). Results: The H-model demonstrates superior discriminative ability, with a higher ROC-AUC score (76.34%) than the NH-model (74.98%). Significant Wilcoxon test results confirm that incorporating historical information improves consistently predictive accuracy for treatment outcomes. The better performance of the H-model might be attributed to its consideration of latent HIV reservoirs, probably obtained when leveraging historical information. The findings emphasize the importance of temporal dynamics in mutations, offering insights into HIV infection complexities. However, our result also shows that prediction accuracy remains relatively high even when no historical information is available. Supplementary information: Supplementary material is available.
Machine Learning,Quantitative Methods
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether the use of historical information (such as the historical records of virus mutations, the time dynamics of their occurrence, and the accompanying viral load measurements) can enhance the predictive ability when predicting the effectiveness of HIV antiviral treatment, and how it differs from using only current or the latest available data. Specifically, the researchers introduced a method to weigh the impact of mutations, taking into account the time dynamics of mutations, changes in viral load, and the referenced Stanford Mutation - Drug Resistance Score Sheet. By comparing the model with historical information (H - model) and the model without using historical information (NH - model), the researchers aimed to evaluate the role of historical information in improving the accuracy of predicting treatment outcomes. The core problem of the paper is to explore how to improve the predictive ability of HIV antiviral treatment outcomes by integrating the time dynamics of virus mutations. This not only involves how to effectively use the mutation information detected in past genotype tests, but also factors such as the time and frequency of these mutations and the accompanying changes in viral load, in order to more accurately predict the treatment effect. The study found that the model using historical information showed a higher ROC - AUC score in predicting treatment outcomes, demonstrating the importance of historical information for improving prediction accuracy.