Arina Odnoblyudova,Çağlar Hizli,ST John,Andrea Cognolato,Anne Juuti,Simo Särkkä,Kirsi Pietiläinen,Pekka Marttinen
Abstract:In biomedical applications it is often necessary to estimate a physiological response to a treatment consisting of multiple components, and learn the separate effects of the components in addition to the joint effect. Here, we extend existing probabilistic nonparametric approaches to explicitly address this problem. We also develop a new convolution-based model for composite treatment-response curves that is more biologically interpretable. We validate our models by estimating the impact of carbohydrate and fat in meals on blood glucose. By differentiating treatment components, incorporating their dosages, and sharing statistical information across patients via a hierarchical multi-output Gaussian process, our method improves prediction accuracy over existing approaches, and allows us to interpret the different effects of carbohydrates and fat on the overall glucose response.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to estimate the impact of treatments composed of multiple components on physiological responses, and be able to distinguish the individual effects of each component as well as their combined effects. Specifically, the author focuses on the impact of multiple nutrients in food (such as carbohydrates and fats) on blood - glucose dynamics. By extending the existing probabilistic non - parametric methods, the author has developed a new convolution - based model to simulate the compound treatment - response curve, which is more in line with biological interpretations. The goals of the paper are:
1. Establish an overall treatment - response function \( f_r \) that can make personalized predictions of the physiological quantity \( y \) under different treatment conditions.
2. Evaluate each component function \( f_{rq} \) and its contribution to the overall response \( f_r \).
### Background and Motivation of the Paper
In biomedical applications, it is often necessary to estimate the impact of treatments composed of multiple components on physiological responses and learn the individual and combined effects of these components. For example, in diabetes management, accurately modeling the impact of different dietary components (such as carbohydrates and fats) on blood - glucose levels is crucial for formulating personalized treatment plans. Existing methods are usually only able to model a single overall response curve and cannot capture the interactions between multiple treatment components.
### Overview of the Methods
The author proposes three non - parametric models to solve the above problems:
1. **GP - Resp**: This is an additive non - parametric Bayesian model, in which the baseline and treatment - response functions are both modeled by Gaussian processes (GP). The response \( f_{rq} \) of each treatment component is decomposed into a response shape \( f_t \) and a response magnitude \( f_m \).
2. **GP - LFM**: This is a method based on the Latent Force Model (LFM), which describes the change of the response over time through a linear ordinary differential equation (ODE) and solves this ODE system to obtain the overall response.
3. **GP - Conv**: This is a convolution - based model that simulates the interaction between the sugar and fat responses through convolution operations. This model assumes that the main driving component is carbohydrates, while other components (such as fats) affect the overall response by modifying the shape and position of the response.
### Experimental Results
The author conducted experiments using a real - world blood - glucose dataset from Helsinki University Hospital, which includes continuous blood - glucose monitoring data and patients' diet records. The experimental results show that the non - parametric models outperform the parametric models in all evaluation metrics (RMSE, MAE, MNLL). In particular, the GP - Conv model performs the best numerically, and its RMSE and MAE results are better than all parametric and existing non - parametric methods.
### Biological Interpretations
From a biological perspective, the results of the GP - Conv model reveal that carbohydrates have a greater immediate impact on blood - glucose levels, while the impact of fats is more delayed and smaller. This finding is consistent with the known physiological mechanisms, that is, carbohydrates are rapidly converted into blood - glucose, while the metabolic process of fats is slower and the impact on blood - glucose is also relatively lagging.
### Summary
This paper successfully solves the problem of the impact of multi - component treatments on physiological responses by developing new non - parametric models and provides more accurate and biologically interpretable predictions. These models have important clinical value in practical applications, especially in personalized medicine and diabetes management.