The two upper critical dimensions of the Ising and Potts models

Kay Joerg Wiese,Jesper Lykke Jacobsen
2024-04-22
Abstract:We derive the exact actions of the $Q$-state Potts model valid on any graph, first for the spin degrees of freedom, and second for the Fortuin-Kasteleyn clusters. In both cases the field is a traceless $Q$-component scalar field $\Phi^\alpha$. For the Ising model ($Q=2$), the field theory for the spins has upper critical dimension $d_{\rm c}^{\rm spin}=4$, whereas for the clusters it has $d_{\rm c}^{\rm cluster}=6$. As a consequence, the probability for three points to be in the same cluster is not given by mean-field theory for $d$ within $4<d<6$. We estimate the associated universal structure constant as $C=\sqrt{6-d}+ {\cal O}(6-d)^{3/2}$. This shows that some observables in the Ising model have an upper critical dimension of 4, while others have an upper critical dimension of $6$. Combining perturbative results from the $\epsilon=6-d$ expansion with a non-perturbative treatment close to dimension $d=4$ allows us to locate the shape of the critical domain of the Potts model in the whole $(Q,d)$ plane.
High Energy Physics - Theory,Statistical Mechanics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on two aspects: 1. **Upper critical dimensions of the Ising model and the Potts model**: The authors derived the exact action of the Q - state Potts model valid on arbitrary graphs, for spin degrees of freedom and Fortuin - Kasteleyn clusters respectively. For the Ising model (Q = 2), the action of spins has an upper critical dimension \(d_{\text{spin}}^c=4\), while the action of clusters has an upper critical dimension \(d_{\text{cluster}}^c = 6\). This means that in the dimensional range \(4 < d < 6\), the probability that three points belong to the same cluster cannot be given by the mean - field theory. 2. **Estimation of the structure constant**: The paper estimated the universal structure constant \(C\) related to this phenomenon, in the form of: \[ C=\sqrt{6 - d}+O((6 - d)^{3/2}) \] This indicates that in the Ising model, the upper critical dimension of some observables is 4, while that of other observables is 6. By combining the perturbative results of the \(\epsilon = 6 - d\) expansion and the non - perturbative treatment close to the dimension \(d = 4\), the authors were able to determine the shape of the critical region of the Potts model in the (Q, d) plane. This helps to better understand the phase - transition behavior and critical properties of these models in different dimensions.