A Comprehensive Study of Governance Issues in Decentralized Finance Applications

Wei Ma,Chenguang Zhu,Ye Liu,Xiaofei Xie,Yi Li

2024-01-11

Abstract:Decentralized Finance (DeFi) is a prominent application of smart contracts, representing a novel financial paradigm in contrast to centralized finance. While DeFi applications are rapidly emerging on mainstream blockchain platforms, their quality varies greatly, presenting numerous challenges, particularly in terms of their governance mechanisms. In this paper, we present a comprehensive study of governance issues in DeFi applications. Drawing upon insights from industry reports and academic research articles, we develop a taxonomy to categorize these governance issues. We collect and build a dataset of 4,446 audit reports from 17 Web3 security companies, categorizing their governance issues according to our constructed taxonomy. We conducted a thorough analysis of governance issues and identified vulnerabilities in governance design and implementation, e.g., voting sybil attack and proposal front-running. Our findings highlight a significant observation: the disparity between smart contract code and DeFi whitepapers plays a central role in these governance issues. As an initial step to address the challenges of code-whitepaper consistency checks for DeFi applications, we built a machine-learning-based prototype, and validated its performance on eight widely used DeFi projects, achieving a 56.14% F1 score and a 80% recall. Our study culminates in providing several key practical implications for various DeFi stakeholders, including developers, users, researchers, and regulators, aiming to deepen the understanding of DeFi governance issues and contribute to the robust growth of DeFi systems.

Software Engineering

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve

This paper aims to comprehensively study governance issues in decentralized finance (DeFi) applications. Specifically, the paper attempts to address the following major issues:

1. **Classification of Governance Mechanisms**:
- The paper develops a taxonomy for categorizing governance issues in DeFi applications by analyzing industry reports and academic research articles. This taxonomy helps in systematically understanding and assessing the nature and severity of governance issues.

2. **Identification and Analysis of Governance Issues**:
- The paper collects 4,446 audit reports from 17 Web3 security companies and conducts a detailed analysis of the governance issues in these reports based on the developed taxonomy. The study finds that vulnerabilities in governance design and implementation (such as voting Sybil attacks and proposal front-running) are among the major governance issues.

3. **Consistency Check Between White Papers and Actual Implementation**:
- The paper points out that a significant issue in DeFi projects is the inconsistency between the governance structure described in the white paper and the actual implementation. This inconsistency can lead to malicious exploitation of governance mechanisms, harming users' interests. To address this, the research team developed a prototype tool based on large language models (LLM) to automatically detect consistency between white papers and actual code. This tool was validated on eight widely used DeFi projects, achieving an F1 score of 56.14% and a recall rate of 80%.

4. **Practical Impact of Governance Challenges**:
- The paper explores the impact of governance issues on the DeFi ecosystem, including effects on user trust, investment decisions, and project sustainability. The study finds that transparent and effective governance mechanisms are crucial for building trust among users and investors.

### Major Contributions

1. **Taxonomy of DeFi Governance**:
- The paper creates a detailed taxonomy of DeFi governance, providing a structured framework for understanding and categorizing DeFi governance issues.

2. **Comprehensive Analysis of DeFi Governance Issues**:
- Through in-depth analysis of audit reports, the paper reveals the current problems, challenges, and unmet needs in DeFi governance, highlighting key issues that require urgent resolution.

3. **Consistency Check Tool Between White Papers and Implementation**:
- The paper develops a new prototype tool that leverages the capabilities of large language models (LLM) to automatically detect consistency between the governance structures described in DeFi project white papers and their actual implementation, paving the way for improved transparency and integrity in DeFi governance.

### Conclusion

Through a systematic research approach, this paper comprehensively analyzes governance issues in DeFi applications and proposes specific solutions and tools. The research findings are significant for multiple stakeholders in the DeFi field (including developers, users, researchers, and regulators) and contribute to the robust and sustainable development of DeFi systems.