Together apart: the influence of increased crowd heterogeneity on crowd dynamics at bottlenecks

Paul Geoerg,Ann Katrin Boomers,Maxine Berthiaume,Maik Boltes,Max Kinateder

2023-11-02

Abstract:Individual differences in mobility (e.g., due to wheelchair use) are often ignored in the prediction of crowd movement. Consequently, engineering tools cannot fully describe the impact of vulnerable populations on egress performance. To contribute to closing this gap, we performed laboratory experiments with 25 pedestrians with varying mobility profiles. The control condition comprised only participants without any additional equipment; in the luggage condition and the wheelchair condition, two participants at the center of the group either carried suitcases or used a wheelchair. We found that individuals using wheelchairs and to a lesser degree those carrying luggage needed longer to pass through the bottleneck, which also affected those walking behind them. This led to slower times to fully clear the bottleneck in the wheelchair and luggage condition compared to the control group. The results challenge the status quo in existing approaches to calculating egress performance and other key performance metrics in crowd dynamics.

Physics and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the impact of individual mobility differences on crowd dynamics in bottleneck areas (such as doors or narrow passages), especially when the crowd includes wheelchair users and people carrying luggage. The study was conducted through laboratory experiments involving 25 participants with different mobility characteristics. Three conditions were set up for the experiment: a control group (all participants without additional equipment), a luggage group (two participants carrying suitcases), and a wheelchair group (two participants using wheelchairs). The study found that the time to pass through the bottleneck significantly increased in both the wheelchair group and the luggage group, affecting not only the individuals directly using wheelchairs or carrying luggage but also those behind them. The results indicate that existing methods need to be re-evaluated when considering key performance indicators of evacuation performance and other crowd dynamics, as these methods are typically based on homogeneous crowd data and do not adequately account for mobility differences. Therefore, this study challenges existing methods of predicting crowd movement and emphasizes the importance of considering crowd heterogeneity in engineering design.