An alternative spontaneous symmetry breaking pattern for $\rm{U}(1)$ with no gapless Goldstone mode

Huan-Qiang Zhou,Qian-Qian Shi,Yan-Wei Dai

2023-11-01

Abstract:An emergent gapless Goldstone mode originates from continuous spontaneous symmetry breaking, which has become a doctrine since the pioneering work by Goldstone [J. Goldstone, Nuovo Cimento \textbf{19}, 154 (1961)]. However, we argue that it is possible for a continuous symmetry group $\rm{U}(1)$ to make an exceptional case, simply due to the well-known mathematical result that a continuous symmetry group $\rm{U}(1)$ may be regarded as a limit of a discrete symmetry group $Z_q$ when $q$ tends to infinity. As a consequence, spontaneous symmetry breaking for such a continuous symmetry group $\rm{U}(1)$ does not necessarily lead to any gapless Goldstone mode. This is explicitly explained for an anisotropic extension of the ferromagnetic spin-1 biquadratic model. In a sense, this model provides an illustrative example regarding the dichotomy between continuity and discreteness.

Strongly Correlated Electrons

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore a new pattern of spontaneous symmetry breaking (SSB) in the continuous symmetry group U(1). In this pattern, no gapless Goldstone mode will be generated. The traditional view is that when a continuous symmetry group is spontaneously broken, one or more gapless Goldstone modes will accompany it, which is the conclusion drawn according to the Goldstone theorem. However, the author proposes a special case, that is, when the U(1) symmetry group is regarded as the limit case of a discrete symmetry group \(Z_q\) as \(q \rightarrow \infty\), the spontaneous symmetry breaking of U(1) may not lead to the generation of any gapless Goldstone mode.

To verify this theory, the paper uses an anisotropic extension of the ferromagnetic spin - 1 biquadratic model as an example. Specifically, the paper studies the ground - state phase diagram of this model under specific parameters, especially on the two characteristic lines of \(J_y/J_z = 1\) and \(J_x = 0\), and discovers the existence of a special SSB pattern, whose remarkable feature is that no gapless Goldstone mode is generated. This pattern leads to infinitely degenerate ground states, which are scale - invariant and can be represented as factorized states, and whose fractal dimension \(d_f\) is zero.

Through numerical simulation and theoretical analysis, the paper shows how this special SSB pattern is realized in a quantum many - body system, thereby revealing a new state of quantum matter. This finding not only challenges the traditional understanding of continuous symmetry breaking but also provides a new perspective for exploring more non - traditional SSB patterns.