Law-Invariant Return and Star-Shaped Risk Measures

Roger J. A. Laeven,Emanuela Rosazza Gianin,Marco Zullino

2023-10-30

Abstract:This paper presents novel characterization results for classes of law-invariant star-shaped functionals. We begin by establishing characterizations for positively homogeneous and star-shaped functionals that exhibit second- or convex-order stochastic dominance consistency. Building on these characterizations, we proceed to derive Kusuoka-type representations for these functionals, shedding light on their mathematical structure and intimate connections to Value-at-Risk and Expected Shortfall. Furthermore, we offer representations of general law-invariant star-shaped functionals as robustifications of Value-at-Risk. Notably, our results are versatile, accommodating settings that may, or may not, involve monotonicity and/or cash-additivity. All of these characterizations are developed within a general locally convex topological space of random variables, ensuring the broad applicability of our results in various financial, insurance and probabilistic contexts.

Risk Management,Probability

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the paper attempts to solve

This paper aims to solve new representation problems related to law - invariance and star - shaped functionals. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following points:

1. **Representation of positively homogeneous and star - shaped functions**:
- Establish representation results of positively homogeneous and star - shaped functions under the second - order stochastic dominance (SSD) and convex - order stochastic dominance (CSD) consistency.

2. **Kusuoka - type representation**:
- Derive the Kusuoka - type representation of these functions, revealing their mathematical structures and their close connections with Value - at - Risk (VaR) and Expected Shortfall (ES).

3. **Robustification of general law - invariant star - shaped functions**:
- Provide representation methods for general law - invariant star - shaped functions as the robustification of VaR. These representation methods do not depend on properties such as monotonicity and cash - additivity.

4. **Applications in generalized locally convex topological spaces**:
- All these representation results are developed in a generalized locally convex topological space, ensuring the wide application of these results in multiple fields such as finance, insurance, and probability theory.

### Main contributions

1. **Filling the gaps in the literature**:
- This paper fills the gaps in the existing literature regarding the representation of star - shaped functions, especially for those functions that do not satisfy monotonicity and cash - additivity.

2. **New representation results**:
- Propose new representation results, especially for star - shaped functions with SSD and CSD consistency. These results can be regarded as independent points of interest.

3. **Robustification representation**:
- Conduct robustification representation for general law - invariant star - shaped functions, showing that these representations are still valid without depending on monotonicity and cash - additivity.

4. **Extension to positively homogeneous functions**:
- These results are further extended to positively homogeneous functions, thus providing new representation results for return - risk measures with SSD consistency.

### Formulas and mathematical representations

- **Definition of star - shaped functions**:
\[
f(\lambda X) \leq \lambda f(X)+(1 - \lambda) f(0), \quad \forall \lambda \in (0, 1), \quad \forall X \in X
\]

- **Definition of risk measures**:
\[
\rho(\lambda X)=\lambda \rho(X), \quad \forall \lambda \in \mathbb{R}_+, \quad \forall X \in X
\]

- **Definitions of VaR and ES**:
\[
\text{VaR}_\beta(X)=\inf \{x \in \mathbb{R} \mid P(X \leq x) \geq \beta \}
\]
\[
\text{ES}_\beta(X)=\frac{1}{1 - \beta} \int_\beta^1 \text{VaR}_m(X) \, dm, \quad \beta \in [0, 1)
\]

- **Definitions of SSD and CSD consistency**:
\[
\rho(X) \geq \rho(Y) \quad \text{if} \quad X \succeq_2 Y
\]
\[
f(X) \geq f(Y) \quad \text{if} \quad X