Visibility graph analysis of crude oil futures markets: Insights from the COVID-19 pandemic and Russia-Ukraine conflict

Yan-Hong Yang,Ying-Lin Liu,Ying-Hui Shao

2024-06-12

Abstract:Drawing inspiration from the significant impact of the ongoing Russia-Ukraine conflict and the recent COVID-19 pandemic on global financial markets, this study conducts a thorough analysis of three key crude oil futures markets: WTI, Brent, and Shanghai (SC). Employing the visibility graph (VG) methodology, we examine both static and dynamic characteristics using daily and high-frequency data. We identified a clear power-law decay in most VG degree distributions and highlighted the pronounced clustering tendencies within crude oil futures VGs. Our results also confirm an inverse correlation between clustering coefficient and node degree and further reveal that all VGs not only adhere to the small-world property but also exhibit intricate assortative mixing. Through the time-varying characteristics of VGs, we found that WTI and Brent demonstrate aligned behavior, while the SC market, with its unique trading mechanics, deviates. The 5-minute VGs' assortativity coefficient provides a deeper understanding of these markets' reactions to the pandemic and geopolitical events. Furthermore, the differential responses during the COVID-19 and Russia-Ukraine conflict underline the unique sensitivities of each market to global disruptions. Overall, this research offers profound insights into the structure, dynamics, and adaptability of these essential commodities markets in the face of worldwide challenges.

Statistical Finance,General Finance

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the issue of studying the dynamic characteristics of the crude oil futures market during the COVID-19 pandemic and the Russia-Ukraine conflict through the method of visibility graph analysis. Specifically, the paper focuses on three key crude oil futures markets: West Texas Intermediate (WTI), Brent Crude, and Shanghai Crude Oil Futures (SC). The researchers used the Visibility Graph (VG) method to analyze the static and dynamic characteristics of these markets and explored the performance of the data at different time resolutions.

The main contributions of the paper are:
1. **Methodological Innovation**: For the first time, the visibility graph method is applied to the analysis of the Shanghai crude oil futures market.
2. **Market Dynamics**: It reveals the different responses of the WTI, Brent, and SC markets during the pandemic and geopolitical events.
3. **Network Properties**: Through attributes such as the degree distribution and clustering coefficient of the visibility graph, it demonstrates the changes in the market at the network level.

The research results show that the behavior of the WTI and Brent markets is relatively consistent, while the SC market, due to its unique trading mechanism, exhibits different characteristics in some aspects. Additionally, the paper finds that these markets have different sensitivities and adaptive capabilities when facing major global shocks.