A Critical Assessment of Electronic Structure Descriptors for Predicting Perovskite Catalytic Properties

Ryan Jacobs,Jian Liu,Harry Abernathy,Dane Morgan

2023-10-27

Abstract:The discovery and design of new materials which can efficiently catalyze the oxygen reduction and evolution reactions at reduced temperatures is important for facilitating the widespread adoption of fuel cell and electrolyzer technologies. Numerous studies have produced correlations between catalytic properties, such as oxygen surface exchange or electrode area specific resistance (ASR), and properties of the catalyst material. However, correlations have historically been limited in scope (e.g., using only a few materials or at a single temperature) and it has been difficult to provide detailed assessments of their robustness. Here, we assess the ability of the O p-band center electronic structure descriptor, obtained from density functional theory (DFT) calculations, to correlate with oxygen surface exchange rates, diffusivities, and area specific resistances for a large database of perovskite oxide catalytic properties. By data mining the literature, we obtain 747 catalytic property value data points spanning 299 unique perovskite compositions from 313 studies. We assess linear correlations of each property with the O p-band center and find generally modest correlations that are qualitatively useful (prediction mean absolute errors of about 0.5 log units are typical), where the correlations are improved at higher temperatures (e.g., 800 °C vs. 500 °C) and significantly improve when considering fits to the subset of materials which have multiple independent measurements. These findings suggest that the spread of property data is significantly influenced by experimental uncertainty, and subsequent measurements of additional materials will likely improve the O p-band center correlations.

Materials Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve

The main purpose of this paper is to evaluate the correlation between the O p-band center electronic structure descriptor and the performance of perovskite catalysts, and to explore the robustness and accuracy of this correlation.

Specifically, the paper attempts to address the following issues:
1. **Correlation Assessment of Perovskite Material Catalytic Performance**: By collecting experimental data from a large number of literature sources, the paper evaluates the correlation between the O p-band center descriptor and the surface exchange rate, diffusion coefficient, and area-specific resistance (ASR) of perovskite catalysts. This data covers 299 different perovskite material compositions, totaling 747 catalytic performance data points.
2. **Temperature Dependence Analysis**: The study investigates how the correlation between the O p-band center descriptor and catalytic performance changes at different temperatures (e.g., 500°C and 800°C).
3. **Quantification of Experimental Uncertainty**: By comparing data from multiple independent measurements, the paper quantifies the impact of experimental uncertainty on the correlation. The results show that experimental errors significantly affect the quality of the correlation, while multiple measurements can substantially improve it.
4. **Relationships Between Different Catalytic Performances**: The paper assesses the interrelationships between different catalytic performances, such as the linear relationship between the surface exchange rate (k*) and the diffusion coefficient (D*), as well as the relationship between k* and ASR.

Overall, the paper aims to validate the effectiveness and limitations of the O p-band center descriptor as a predictive tool for catalyst performance through large-scale database analysis. Although the O p-band center descriptor remains useful for qualitative assessments, its quantitative predictive capability is limited, especially at lower temperatures. Future research may adopt more accurate and faster machine learning methods to replace traditional DFT descriptor methods.