Characterizing the heterogeneity of membrane liquid-ordered domains

Tanmoy Sarkar,Oded Farago
2023-10-22
Abstract:We use a lattice model of a ternary mixture containing saturated and unsaturated lipids with cholesterol (Chol), to study the structural properties characterizing the coexistence between the liquid-disordered and liquid-ordered phases. Depending on the affinity of the saturated and unsaturated lipids, the system may exhibit macroscopic (thermodynamic) liquid-liquid phase separation, or be divided into small-size liquid-ordered domains surrounded by a liquid-disordered matrix. In both cases, it is found that the nano-scale structure of the liquid-ordered regions is heterogeneous, and that they are partitioned into Chol-rich sub-domains and Chol-free, gel-like, nano-clusters. This emerges as a characteristic feature of the liquid-ordered state, which helps distinguishing between liquid-ordered domains in a two-phase mixture, and similar-looking domains in a one-phase mixture that are rich in saturated lipids and Chol, but are merely thermal density fluctuations. The nano-structure heterogeneity of the liquid-ordered phase can be detected by suitable experimental spectroscopic methods, and is observed also in atomistic computer simulations.
Soft Condensed Matter,Statistical Mechanics,Biological Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper mainly discusses the heterogeneity of liquid-ordered (Lo) domains in the cell membrane, which is an important topic in biological membrane physics. A lattice model containing saturated and unsaturated lipids as well as cholesterol (Chol) was used to investigate the structural properties between the liquid-disordered (Ld) and liquid-ordered phases under different conditions of lipid affinity. The paper focuses on whether the system exhibits macroscopic or microscopic liquid-liquid phase separation under different saturation and unsaturation lipid conditions. In the liquid-ordered phase, it was found that there are cholesterol-enriched subdomains and cholesterol-poor, gel-like nanoclusters. The heterogeneity of these nanoscale structures is considered to be a characteristic of the liquid-ordered state, which helps distinguish liquid-ordered domains in phase mixtures from similar-looking regions in single-phase mixtures. This nanoscale structural heterogeneity can be detected by experimental spectroscopy methods and has also been observed in atomic force simulations. The paper mentions that some mixtures exhibit macroscopic liquid-liquid phase separation (Type II), while others exhibit nanoscale localized phase separation (Type I). In Type II mixtures, the two liquid phases can separate thermodynamically, while in Type I mixtures, there is no obvious macroscopic phase separation but the presence of nanoscale liquid-ordered domains, which may be a result of thermal density fluctuations. By varying the model parameters, researchers were able to transform the mixtures from Type II to Type I while maintaining the internal heterogeneous distribution. By simulating systems under different affinity parameters, the study revealed the heterogeneity of liquid-ordered phases at the nanoscale. This internal structural heterogeneity persists even when macroscopic phase separation disappears (becomes Type I). This suggests that the existence of nanoclusters may be a defining property of the liquid-ordered state, which can be detected through appropriate experimental methods and is helpful in plotting phase boundaries of lipid mixtures. In conclusion, this paper aims to quantitatively study the internal structure of liquid-ordered phases, especially in different types of mixtures, to understand how cholesterol and different lipids affect membrane structure and phase behavior at the nanoscale. These findings are crucial for understanding the dynamics of cell membranes and biological processes such as signal transduction and membrane transport.