Horizonless black hole mimickers with spin

Ulf Danielsson,Suvendu Giri
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.109.024038
2024-01-25
Abstract:In this paper, we study rotating horizon less black shells as an alternative to Kerr black holes. We make use of Ernst's potential to solve the Einstein equations perturbatively in the angular momentum $a$. Calculating to order $a^6$, we find accurate predictions up to about $a=0.45$, where the quadrupole moment is predicted to be around $1\%$ higher than its Kerr value; higher multipole moments show deviation of the order of $\sim 10\%$. Our analysis takes into account deformations of the black shells, and we propose that it can be used for numerical simulations comparing gravitational waves emitted by orbiting black shells with those emitted by orbiting black holes. In our analysis, we make extensive use of relativistic hydrodynamics, and discover an intricate structure of circulating flows of fluid and heat on the black shell, sustained by the Unruh effect.
General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,High Energy Physics - Theory
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore rotating black - hole analogues without event horizons (i.e., rotating black shells) as alternatives to Kerr black holes. Specifically, the authors studied these rotating black shells, used the Ernst potential to solve the Einstein equations, and predicted the properties of these black shells through a sixth - order expansion of the angular momentum \(a\), especially the differences in their multipole moments from Kerr black holes. In addition, the paper also explored the stability of these black shells and the behavior of the matter on their surfaces, such as hydrodynamic properties, including heat conduction and shear viscosity. ### Main research contents: 1. **Construction of rotating black shells**: The authors proposed a rotating black - shell model, which does not have a true event horizon but is composed of a massless open - string gas attached to the membrane that forms the black shell. 2. **Solution of the Einstein equations**: Using the Ernst potential method, the authors carried out a sixth - order expansion of the angular momentum \(a\) for the Einstein equations to accurately predict the properties of the black shell. 3. **Calculation of multipole moments**: The authors calculated the multipole moments of the black shell and compared them with those of the Kerr black hole. They found that when \(a\approx0.45m\), the quadrupole moment is about 1% higher than the Kerr value, and the deviations of the higher - order multipole moments are about 10%. 4. **Stability of black shells**: The authors discussed the stability of black shells and proposed a mechanism that enables the black shell to remain stable when subjected to small perturbations. 5. **Hydrodynamic analysis**: The authors used the relativistic hydrodynamic method to study the fluid flow and heat conduction on the rotating black shell and found that these flow and heat conduction patterns are very complex, similar to the trade winds on Earth. ### Research significance: - **Contribution to theoretical physics**: This research provides a new perspective for understanding alternative models of black holes, especially in the quantum gravity theory, where the traditional concept of black holes may need to be re - examined. - **Impact on observational astronomy**: Through a detailed study of rotating black shells, the paper provides some potential observational signals that can help distinguish black shells from traditional black holes, thus providing guidance for future astronomical observations. ### Formula examples: - **Ernst potential**: \[ \xi=\frac{1 - E}{1 + E}, \quad E = f + i\Omega \] where \(E\) is a complex function defined by the metric functions \(f\) and \(\omega\). - **Compact form of the Einstein equation**: \[ (\xi\xi^{*}-1)\nabla^{2}\xi = 2\xi^{*}\nabla\xi\cdot\nabla\xi \] where \(\nabla\) and \(\nabla^{2}\) are the two - dimensional gradient and Laplace operators respectively. - **Calculation of multipole moments**: \[ M_{0}=m+(\delta - 1)\sigma \] \[ M_{2}=-m^{3}-3(\delta - 1)m^{2}\sigma-(\delta - 2)\delta m\sigma^{2}+\sigma^{3}\left(-\frac{\delta^{3}}{3}+\delta^{2}+\frac{2}{15}\delta(q_{2}+10)-2\right) \] Through these studies, the authors not only provided new insights for theoretical physics but also provided valuable references for future astronomical observations.