Resolving the Corbino Shockley-Ramo Paradox for Hydrodynamic Current Noise

Aaron Hui

2023-10-13

Abstract:Johnson noise thermometry enables direct measurement of the electron temperature, a valuable probe of many-body systems. Practical use of this technique calls for non-equilibrium generalizations of the Johnson-Nyquist theorem. For a hydrodynamic Corbino device, however, a naïve use of the Shockley-Ramo theorem alongside the "Corbino paradox" leads to yet another paradox: bulk velocity fluctuations cannot be measured by the contacts. In this work, we resolve the unphysical "Corbino Shockley-Ramo paradox" by correctly formulating the hydrodynamic Shockley-Ramo problem. This allows us to properly formulate the problem of current noise in an hydrodynamic multi-terminal device of arbitrary geometry, as well as validate a previously unjustified assumption for rectangular geometry results. As an example, we compute the Johnson noise in a hydrodynamic Corbino device, where we find a suppression of Johnson noise with magnetic field. This unusual characteristic serves as a strong signature of viscous hydrodynamic behavior.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Strongly Correlated Electrons

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problem does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to solve the **Corbino Shockley - Ramo paradox**, a theoretical dilemma encountered in dealing with hydrodynamic current noise. Specifically:

1. **Limitations of Johnson - noise thermometry**:
- Johnson - noise thermometry is a technique for directly measuring the electron temperature, which relies on the Johnson - Nyquist theorem (fluctuation - dissipation theorem). However, in a non - equilibrium state, especially for multi - terminal devices with complex geometries, this theorem needs to be generalized.
- For the hydrodynamic Corbino device, if the Shockley - Ramo theorem is simply applied, a paradox will result: the bulk velocity fluctuation cannot be measured through the contact points.

2. **The Corbino paradox**:
- In the Corbino geometry, even without a local electric field, a finite current will dissipate heat locally. This leads to a corollary paradox: according to the Shockley - Ramo theorem, any bulk velocity fluctuation will not produce a measurable current fluctuation at the contact points.
- This means that the Shockley - Ramo theorem cannot be used to correctly describe the current noise in Corbino devices, thus hindering the study of current noise in devices of arbitrary geometries.

### Main contributions of the paper

By introducing the "**hydrodynamic Shockley - Ramo problem**", the author has solved the above paradox and proposed a current - noise formula applicable to any multi - terminal device. Specifically:

1. **Redefining the boundary conditions**:
- The author introduced new boundary conditions, enabling the correct description of the relationship between the bulk velocity fluctuation and the contact - point current fluctuation in the Corbino geometry.

2. **Generalizing the Shockley - Ramo theorem**:
- The author generalized the Shockley - Ramo theorem to make it applicable to hydrodynamic systems. By introducing a new linear operator \( L^{-1} \), the author was able to correctly calculate the total current caused by internal carriers.

3. **Analytical solutions and numerical simulations**:
- The author demonstrated the Johnson - noise suppression phenomenon caused by the magnetic field through specific calculations of the Corbino geometry. This phenomenon is a strong feature of viscous hydrodynamic behavior.

4. **Verifying previous assumptions**:
- The author also verified the previously unproven Shockley - Ramo assumptions in rectangular geometries, further perfecting the relevant theory.

### Summary

By introducing a new mathematical framework and physical model, this paper has successfully solved the Corbino Shockley - Ramo paradox and provided a general method for studying current noise in devices of arbitrary geometries. This result not only helps to understand the noise characteristics in hydrodynamic systems but also provides theoretical support for Johnson - noise thermometry in experiments.