Yeonsu Jung,Thomas Plumb-Reyes,Hao-Yu Greg Lin,L. Mahadevan
Abstract:Random packings of stiff rods are self-supporting mechanical structures stabilized by long range interactions induced by contacts. To understand the geometrical and topological complexity of the packings, we first deploy X-ray computerized tomography to unveil the structure of the packing. This allows us to directly visualize the spatial variations in density, orientational order and the entanglement, a mesoscopic field that we define in terms of a local average crossing number, a measure of the topological complexity of the packing. We find that increasing the aspect ratio of the constituent rods in a packing leads to a proliferation of regions of strong entanglement that eventually percolate through the system, and correlated with a sharp transition in the mechanical stability of the packing. To corroborate our experimental findings, we use numerical simulations of contacting elastic rods and characterize their stability to static and dynamic loadings. Our experiments and computations lead us to an entanglement phase diagram which we also populate using published experimental data from pneumatically tangled filaments, worm blobs, and bird nests along with additional numerical simulations using these data sets. Together, these show the regimes associated with mechanically stable entanglement as a function of the statistics of the packings and loading, with lessons for a range of systems from reconfigurable architectures and textiles to active morphable filamentous assemblies.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand the geometric and topological complexity of randomly arranged rigid slender rods (such as wires, fibers, etc.) under different aspect ratios and their influence on mechanical stability. Specifically, the author studied through experiments and numerical simulations how these rod - like objects form stable structures by intertwining at high aspect ratios and explored the mechanism of this stability.
### Background and Problems of the Paper
1. **Background**:
- A system of randomly arranged spherical or ellipsoidal particles can be characterized by their number density and positional disorder. At a sufficiently high density, these systems will transition to a disordered close - packed state, exhibiting mechanical properties controlled by topological order parameters (such as the average coordination number).
- However, these particle systems usually require boundary constraints to maintain mechanical stability; otherwise, they will become unstable.
- In contrast, long and slender rod - like objects (such as feathers in a bird's nest, randomly arranged felt) can form a solid - like state through intertwining at a lower filling rate, exhibiting mechanical stability.
2. **Problems**:
- The author attempts to understand the geometric and topological complexity of long and slender rod - like objects under different aspect ratios, especially how these complexities affect the mechanical stability of the system.
- Specifically, the author focuses on the following points:
- How to reveal the internal structure of rod - like object packing, including density, orientation order, and degree of intertwining, through X - ray computed tomography (CT) technology.
- How increasing the aspect ratio of rod - like objects leads to an increase in strongly intertwined regions and eventually penetrates throughout the system.
- How this intertwining is related to the sharp change in mechanical stability.
### Experimental and Simulation Methods
1. **Experiment**:
- Use X - ray CT imaging technology to obtain the three - dimensional structure of steel rod packings with different aspect ratios.
- Analyze the local volume fraction, orientation order, contact density, and degree of intertwining in these structures.
- Test the mechanical stability of these packings through dynamic excitation (such as harmonic vibration).
2. **Numerical Simulation**:
- Use numerical simulation to generate randomly arranged rod - like object packings and simulate their behavior under mechanical excitation.
- Compare the packing stabilities at different aspect ratios to verify the experimental results.
### Main Findings
1. **Mechanical Stability**:
- The packings of rod - like objects with a high aspect ratio can resist their own weight and dynamic excitation, forming stable clusters.
- The packings of rod - like objects with a low aspect ratio cannot maintain stability and are prone to collapse.
2. **Geometric and Topological Features**:
- In the packings of rod - like objects with a high aspect ratio, the strongly intertwined regions gradually increase and eventually penetrate throughout the system.
- The degree of intertwining (represented by the local average number of crossings) is closely related to mechanical stability.
3. **Phase Diagram**:
- The author constructed an intertwining phase diagram, describing the mechanical stability and degree of intertwining under different aspect ratios, dynamic loading, and static loading conditions.
- The phase diagram shows that when the aspect ratio exceeds a certain critical value (about 100), the system transitions from an unstable non - intertwined state to a stable intertwined state.
### Conclusion
This paper, through experiments and numerical simulations, reveals the influence of the geometric and topological complexity of long and slender rod - like objects under different aspect ratios on their mechanical stability. The research results not only help to understand similar phenomena in nature (such as the stability of bird's nests), but also provide a theoretical basis for designing reconfigurable structures, textiles, and soft robots, etc.