Critical assessment of $G_0W_0$ calculations for 2D materials: the example of monolayer MoS$_2$

Ronaldo Rodrigues Pela,Cecilia Vona,Sven Lubeck,Ben Alex,Ignacio Gonzalez Oliva,Claudia Draxl

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41524-024-01253-2

2024-04-23

Abstract:Two-dimensional (2D) materials combine many fascinating properties that make them more interesting than their three-dimensional counterparts for a variety of applications. For example, 2D materials exhibit stronger electron-phonon and electron-hole interactions, and their energy gaps and effective carrier masses can be easily tuned. Surprisingly, published band gaps of several 2D materials obtained with the $GW$ approach, the state-of-the-art in electronic-structure calculations, are quite scattered. The details of these calculations, such as the underlying geometry, the starting point, the inclusion of spin-orbit coupling, and the treatment of the Coulomb potential can critically determine how accurate the results are. Taking monolayer MoS$_2$ as a representative material, we employ the linearized augmented planewave + local orbital method to systematically investigate how all these aspects affect the quality of $G_0W_0$ calculations, and also provide a summary of literature data. We conclude that the best overall agreement with experiments and coupled-cluster calculations is found for $G_0W_0$ results with HSE06 as a starting point including spin-orbit coupling, a truncated Coulomb potential, and an analytical treatment of the singularity at $q=0$.

Materials Science,Other Condensed Matter,Chemical Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to address the inconsistency issues in calculating band gaps of two-dimensional (2D) materials using the GW method. Specifically: 1. **Research Background**: 2D materials have garnered significant attention due to their unique electronic, thermal, and optical properties. For instance, their band structures can be easily tuned by external electric fields or strain. However, the band gap values of different 2D materials calculated using the GW method vary greatly, posing challenges for theoretical research. 2. **Core Issue**: When using the GW method (especially the G0W0 approximation) to calculate the band gap of 2D materials such as molybdenum disulfide (MoS2), factors like different geometric structures, initial point selection, treatment of spin-orbit coupling, and the way Coulomb potential is truncated can lead to significant discrepancies in the results. 3. **Research Objective**: The paper systematically investigates how the aforementioned factors affect the quality of G0W0 calculations using monolayer MoS2 as an example and provides a summary of literature data. The study finds that using HSE06 as the initial point, including spin-orbit coupling, truncating the Coulomb potential, and analytically treating the singularity at q=0 can yield results that best match experimental and coupled-cluster calculations. Through these analyses, the paper aims to provide more reliable methods and benchmark datasets for the electronic structure calculations of 2D materials.

Critical assessment of $G_0W_0$ calculations for 2D materials: the example of monolayer MoS$_2$

Efficient and accurate defect level modelling in monolayer MoS$_2$ via GW+DFT with open boundary conditions

Low-scaling GW algorithm applied to twisted transition-metal dichalcogenide heterobilayers

Real-time GW-Ehrenfest-Fan-Migdal method for nonequilibrium 2D materials

Wannier Koopmans Method Calculations of 2D Material Band Gaps.

Reliable density functional and G_0 W_0 approaches to the calculation of bandgaps in 2D materials

Combined subsampling and analytical integration for efficient large-scale GW calculations for 2D systems

Efficient GW calculations in two dimensional materials through a stochastic integration of the screened potential

Electronic structure of low-dimensional inorganic/organic interfaces: Hybrid density functional theory, $G_0W_0$, and electrostatic models

Computational 2D Materials Database: Electronic Structure of Transition-Metal Dichalcogenides and Oxides

Electronic Structures of Monolayer Binary and Ternary 2D Materials: MoS2, WS2, Mo1−xCrxS2, and W1−xCrxS2 Using Density Functional Theory Calculations

All electron GW with linearized augmented plane waves for metals and semiconductors

Impact of Widely Used Approximations to Theg0w0method: an All-Electron Perspective

Precision benchmarks for solids: G0W0 calculations with different basis sets

Combined Sub-Sampling and Analytical Integration for Efficient Large-Scale GW Calculations for 2D Systems

Band structures and $\mathbb{Z}_2$ invariants of two-dimensional transition metal dichalcogenide monolayers from fully-relativistic Dirac-Kohn-Sham theory using Gaussian-type orbitals

Electronic structure, magnetoexcitons and valley polarized electron gas in 2D crystals

Compilation and deciphering MoS 2 's physical properties: Accurate benchmark DFT simulations and assessment of advanced quantum methods

All-electron self-consistent GW in the Matsubara-time domain: implementation and benchmarks of semiconductors and insulators

Two-component $GW$ calculations: Cubic scaling implementation and comparison of vertex corrected and partially self-consistent $GW$ variants