A Proof Synthesis Algorithm for a Mathematical Vernacular in the Calculus of Constructions

Gilles Dowek

2023-10-06

Abstract:We present an incomplete proof synthesis method for the Calculus of Constructions which is always terminating and a complete Vernacular for the Calculus of Constructions based on this method.

Logic in Computer Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

A Complete Proof Synthesis Method for the Cube of Type Systems

Gilles Dowek

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2306.05835

2023-06-09

Abstract:We present a complete proof synthesis method for the eight type systems of Barendregt's cube extended with $\eta$-conversion. Because these systems verify the proofs-as-objects paradigm, the proof synthesis method is a one level process merging unification and resolution. Then we present a variant of this method, which is incomplete but much more efficient. At last we show how to turn this algorithm into a unification algorithm.

Logic in Computer Science
On the mathematical synthesis of equational logics

Marcelo Fiore,Chung-Kil Hur

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2168/lmcs-7(3:12)2011

2011-09-08

Logical Methods in Computer Science

Abstract:We provide a mathematical theory and methodology for synthesising equational logics from algebraic metatheories. We illustrate our methodology by means of two applications: a rational reconstruction of Birkhoff's Equational Logic and a new equational logic for reasoning about algebraic structure with name-binding operators.

computer science, theory & methods,logic
On Integrating Deductive Synthesis and Verification Systems

Etienne Kneuss,Viktor Kuncak,Ivan Kuraj,Philippe Suter

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1304.5661

2013-04-20

Programming Languages

Abstract:We describe techniques for synthesis and verification of recursive functional programs over unbounded domains. Our techniques build on top of an algorithm for satisfiability modulo recursive functions, a framework for deductive synthesis, and complete synthesis procedures for algebraic data types. We present new counterexample-guided algorithms for constructing verified programs. We have implemented these algorithms in an integrated environment for interactive verification and synthesis from relational specifications. Our system was able to synthesize a number of useful recursive functions that manipulate unbounded numbers and data structures.
Schematic Refutations of Formula Schemata

David Cerna,Alexander Leitsch,Anela Lolic

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10817-020-09583-8

2020-02-11

Abstract:Proof schemata are infinite sequences of proofs which are defined inductively. In this paper we present a general framework for schemata of terms, formulas and unifiers and define a resolution calculus for schemata of quantifier-free formulas. The new calculus generalizes and improves former approaches to schematic deduction. As an application of the method we present a schematic refutation formalizing a proof of a weak form of the pigeon hole principle.

Logic in Computer Science
Arithmetical conservation results

Benno van den Berg,Lotte van Slooten

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1706.05901

2017-06-19

Abstract:In this paper we present a proof of Goodman's Theorem, a classical result in the metamathematics of constructivism, which states that the addition of the axiom of choice to Heyting arithmetic in finite types does not increase the collection of provable arithmetical sentences. Our proof relies on several ideas from earlier proofs by other authors, but adds some new ones as well. In particular, we show how a recent paper by Jaap van Oosten can be used to simplify a key step in the proof. We have also included an interesting corollary for classical systems pointed out to us by Ulrich Kohlenbach.

Logic
Propositional Calculus in Coq

Floris van Doorn

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1503.08744

2015-03-30

Logic

Abstract:I formalize important theorems about classical propositional logic in the proof assistant Coq. The main theorems I prove are (1) the soundness and completeness of natural deduction calculus, (2) the equivalence between natural deduction calculus, Hilbert systems and sequent calculus and (3) cut elimination for sequent calculus.
Defining Logical Systems via Algebraic Constraints on Proofs

Alexander V. Gheorghiu,David J. Pym

2023-10-19

Abstract:We present a comprehensive programme analysing the decomposition of proof systems for non-classical logics into proof systems for other logics, especially classical logic, using an algebra of constraints. That is, one recovers a proof system for a target logic by enriching a proof system for another, typically simpler, logic with an algebra of constraints that act as correctness conditions on the latter to capture the former; for example, one may use Boolean algebra to give constraints in a sequent calculus for classical propositional logic to produce a sequent calculus for intuitionistic propositional logic. The idea behind such forms of reduction is to obtain a tool for uniform and modular treatment of proof theory and provide a bridge between semantics logics and their proof theory. The article discusses the theoretical background of the project and provides several illustrations of its work in the field of intuitionistic and modal logics. The results include the following: a uniform treatment of modular and cut-free proof systems for a large class of propositional logics; a general criterion for a novel approach to soundness and completeness of a logic with respect to a model-theoretic semantics; and, a case study deriving a model-theoretic semantics from a proof-theoretic specification of a logic.

Logic in Computer Science,Logic
Automated Completion of Statements and Proofs in Synthetic Geometry: an Approach based on Constraint Solving

Salwa Tabet Gonzalez,Predrag Janičić,Julien Narboux

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4204/EPTCS.398.6

2024-01-22

Abstract:Conjecturing and theorem proving are activities at the center of mathematical practice and are difficult to separate. In this paper, we propose a framework for completing incomplete conjectures and incomplete proofs. The framework can turn a conjecture with missing assumptions and with an under-specified goal into a proper theorem. Also, the proposed framework can help in completing a proof sketch into a human-readable and machine-checkable proof. Our approach is focused on synthetic geometry, and uses coherent logic and constraint solving. The proposed approach is uniform for all three kinds of tasks, flexible and, to our knowledge, unique such approach.

Artificial Intelligence,Logic in Computer Science
Abductive Reasoning in Intuitionistic Propositional Logic via Theorem Synthesis

Paul Tarau

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2205.05728

2022-05-12

Abstract:With help of a compact Prolog-based theorem prover for Intuitionistic Propositional Logic, we synthesize minimal assumptions under which a given formula formula becomes a theorem. After applying our synthesis algorithm to cover basic abductive reasoning mechanisms, we synthesize conjunctions of literals that mimic rows of truth tables in classical or intermediate logics and we abduce conditional hypotheses that turn the theorems of classical or intermediate logics into theorems in intuitionistic logic. One step further, we generalize our abductive reasoning mechanism to synthesize more expressive sequent premises using a minimal set of canonical formulas, to which arbitrary formulas in the calculus can be reduced while preserving their provability. Organized as a self-contained literate Prolog program, the paper supports interactive exploration of its content and ensures full replicability of our results.

Logic in Computer Science
Proof-Based Synthesis of Sorting Algorithms Using Multisets in Theorema

Isabela Drămnesc,Tudor Jebelean

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4204/EPTCS.303.6

2019-09-04

Abstract:Using multisets, we develop novel techniques for mechanizing the proofs of the synthesis conjectures for list-sorting algorithms, and we demonstrate them in the Theorema system. We use the classical principle of extracting the algorithm as a set of rewrite rules based on the witnesses found in the proof of the synthesis conjecture produced from the specification of the desired function (input and output conditions). The proofs are in natural style, using standard rules, but most importantly domain specific inference rules and strategies. In particular the use of multisets allows us to develop powerful strategies for the synthesis of arbitrarily structured recursive algorithms by general Noetherian induction, as well as for the automatic generation of the specifications of all necessary auxiliary functions (insert, merge, split), whose synthesis is performed using the same method.

Logic in Computer Science,Artificial Intelligence,Data Structures and Algorithms
Proof-theoretic methods in quantifier-free definability

Zoltan A. Kocsis

2023-10-06

Abstract:We introduce a proof-theoretic method for showing nondefinability of second-order intuitionistic connectives by quantifier-free schemata. We apply the method to confirm that Taranovsky's "realizability disjunction" connective does not admit a quantifier-free definition, and use it to obtain new results and more nuanced information about the nondefinability of Kreisel's and Połacik's unary connectives. The finitary and combinatorial nature of our method makes it more resilient to changes in metatheory than common semantic approaches, whose robustness tends to waver once we pass to non-classical and especially anti-classical settings. Furthermore, we can easily transcribe the problem-specific subproofs into univalent type theory and check them using the Agda proof assistant.

Logic,Logic in Computer Science
Characterizing Propositional Proofs As Non-Commutative Formulas.

Fu Li,Iddo Tzameret,Zhengyu Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1137/16m1107632

2018-01-01

SIAM Journal on Computing

Abstract:Does every Boolean tautology have a short propositional-calculus proof? Here, a propositional calculus (i.e. Frege) proof is a proof starting from a set of axioms and deriving new Boolean formulas using a set of fixed sound derivation rules. Establishing any super-polynomial size lower bound on Frege proofs (in terms of the size of the formula proved) is a major open problem in proof complexity, and among a handful of fundamental hardness questions in complexity theory by and large. Non-commutative arithmetic formulas, on the other hand, constitute a quite weak computational model, for which exponential-size lower bounds were shown already back in 1991 by Nisan [Nis91] who used a particularly transparent argument. In this work we show that Frege lower bounds in fact follow from corresponding size lower bounds on non-commutative formulas computing certain polynomials (and that such lower bounds on non-commutative formulas must exist, unless NP=coNP). More precisely, we demonstrate a natural association between tautologies $T$ to non-commutative polynomials $p$, such that: if $T$ has a polynomial-size Frege proof then $p$ has a polynomial-size non-commutative arithmetic formula; and conversely, when $T$ is a DNF, if $p$ has a polynomial-size non-commutative arithmetic formula over $GF(2)$ then $T$ has a Frege proof of quasi-polynomial size.
Investigations into Proof Structures

Christoph Wernhard,Wolfgang Bibel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10817-024-09711-8

2024-10-31

Journal of Automated Reasoning

Abstract:We introduce and elaborate a novel formalism for the manipulation and analysis of proofs as objects in a global manner. In this first approach the formalism is restricted to first-order problems characterized by condensed detachment. It is applied in an exemplary manner to a coherent and comprehensive formal reconstruction and analysis of historical proofs of a widely-studied problem due to Łukasiewicz. The underlying approach opens the door towards new systematic ways of generating lemmas in the course of proof search to the effects of reducing the search effort and finding shorter proofs. Among the numerous reported experiments along this line, a proof of Łukasiewicz 's problem was automatically discovered that is much shorter than any proof found before by man or machine.

computer science, artificial intelligence
Canonical Proof nets for Classical Logic

Richard McKinley

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1203.4084

2012-03-19

Abstract:Proof nets provide abstract counterparts to sequent proofs modulo rule permutations; the idea being that if two proofs have the same underlying proof-net, they are in essence the same proof. Providing a convincing proof-net counterpart to proofs in the classical sequent calculus is thus an important step in understanding classical sequent calculus proofs. By convincing, we mean that (a) there should be a canonical function from sequent proofs to proof nets, (b) it should be possible to check the correctness of a net in polynomial time, (c) every correct net should be obtainable from a sequent calculus proof, and (d) there should be a cut-elimination procedure which preserves correctness. Previous attempts to give proof-net-like objects for propositional classical logic have failed at least one of the above conditions. In [23], the author presented a calculus of proof nets (expansion nets) satisfying (a) and (b); the paper defined a sequent calculus corresponding to expansion nets but gave no explicit demonstration of (c). That sequent calculus, called LK\ast in this paper, is a novel one-sided sequent calculus with both additively and multiplicatively formulated disjunction rules. In this paper (a self-contained extended version of [23]), we give a full proof of (c) for expansion nets with respect to LK\ast, and in addition give a cut-elimination procedure internal to expansion nets - this makes expansion nets the first notion of proof-net for classical logic satisfying all four criteria.

Logic,Logic in Computer Science
Weighted, Circular and Semi-Algebraic Proofs

Ilario Bonacina,Maria Luisa Bonet,Jordi Levy

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1613/jair.1.15075

2024-02-11

Journal of Artificial Intelligence Research

Abstract:In recent years there has been an increasing interest in studying proof systems stronger than Resolution, with the aim of building more efficient SAT solvers based on them. In defining these proof systems, we try to find a balance between the power of the proof system (the size of the proofs required to refute a formula) and the difficulty of finding the proofs. In this paper we consider the proof systems circular Resolution, Sherali-Adams, Nullstellensatz and Weighted Resolution and we study their relative power from a theoretical perspective. We prove that circular Resolution, Sherali-Adams and Weighted Resolution are polynomially equivalent proof systems. We also prove that Nullstellensatz is polynomially equivalent to a restricted version of Weighted Resolution. The equivalences carry on also for versions of the systems where the coefficients/weights are expressed in unary. The practical interest in these systems comes from the fact that they admit efficient algorithms to find proofs in case these have small width/degree.

computer science, artificial intelligence
On an elementary proof of the fundamental theorem of algebra

Aivaras Novikas,Juozas Juvencijus Mačys

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10986-024-09651-1

2024-10-18

Lithuanian Mathematical Journal

Abstract:We present an elementary proof of the fundamental theorem of algebra, in which only the most basic notions of calculus are used. Considering discrete quantities instead of continuous functions allows us to obtain a proof that is fairly approachable but maintains the mathematical rigor.

mathematics
Kalmár-style constructive completeness proofs for classical positive propositional calculi

Luiz Henrique Lopes dos Santos

2023-05-09

Abstract:We shall settle the completeness of some classical positive propositional calculi (positive propositional calculi in which the so-called Peirce's law holds) by resorting to a close adaptation of Kalmar's completeness proof procedure. First of all, we shall employ this adaptation to establish the completeness of the most familiar axiomatic characterization of the classical logic of material implication and disjunction. Next, we shall demonstrate that the completeness of the so-called classical positive propositional calculus can be proved either through essentially the same adaptation of Kalmar's procedure or as an immediate consequence of the conjunction of our first result and the circumstance of each positive formula being reducible to a syntactically and semantically equivalent one exhibiting a particular normal form. Finally, by defining disjunction in terms of material implication and so mirroring the classical calculus of material implication and disjunction in the classical implicative calculus, the completeness of the latter, as well as the completeness of the classical calculus of material implication and conjunction, will be shown to follow from the completeness of the former in quite simple and direct ways. It is worth noting that all these completeness proofs will be constructive, that is to say, we can easily extract from each of them an effective method for producing formal deductions of all theses of the axiomatic system concerned.

Logic
Graphical Calculi and their Conjecture Synthesis

Hector Miller-Bakewell

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2010.03914

2020-10-08

Abstract:Categorical Quantum Mechanics, and graphical calculi in particular, has proven to be an intuitive and powerful way to reason about quantum computing. This work continues the exploration of graphical calculi, inside and outside of the quantum computing setting, by investigating the algebraic structures with which we label diagrams. The initial aim for this was Conjecture Synthesis; the algorithmic process of creating theorems. To this process we introduce a generalisation step, which itself requires the ability to infer and then verify parameterised families of theorems. This thesis introduces such inference and verification frameworks, in doing so forging novel links between graphical calculi and fields such as Algebraic Geometry and Galois Theory. These frameworks inspired further research into the design of graphical calculi, and we introduce two important new calculi here. First is the calculus RING, which is initial among ring-based qubit graphical calculi, and in turn inspired the introduction and classification of phase homomorphism pairs also presented here. The second is the calculus ZQ, an edge-decorated calculus which naturally expresses arbitrary qubit rotations, eliminating the need for non-linear rules such as (EU) of ZX. It is expected that these results will be of use to those creating optimisation schemes and intermediate representations for quantum computing, to those creating new graphical calculi, and for those performing conjecture synthesis.

Quantum Physics
Graphical Proof Theory I: Sequent Systems on Undirected Graphs

Matteo Acclavio

2024-02-13

Abstract:In this paper we explore the design of sequent calculi operating on graphs. For this purpose, we introduce a set of logical connectives allowing us to extend the correspondence between cographs and classical propositional formulas to any graph. We then provide sequent calculi operating on these formulas, we prove cut-elimination and that formula encoding the same graph are logically equivalent. We show that these systems provide conservative extensions of multiplicative linear logic (with and without mix) and classical propositional logic. We conclude by showing that one of these systems is equivalent to the graphical logic GS defined via a system of context-free graph rewiring rules, therefore providing an alternative proof of analyticity for this logic over graphs.

Logic in Computer Science

A Proof Synthesis Algorithm for a Mathematical Vernacular in the Calculus of Constructions

A Complete Proof Synthesis Method for the Cube of Type Systems

On the mathematical synthesis of equational logics

On Integrating Deductive Synthesis and Verification Systems

Schematic Refutations of Formula Schemata

Arithmetical conservation results

Propositional Calculus in Coq

Defining Logical Systems via Algebraic Constraints on Proofs

Automated Completion of Statements and Proofs in Synthetic Geometry: an Approach based on Constraint Solving

Abductive Reasoning in Intuitionistic Propositional Logic via Theorem Synthesis

Proof-Based Synthesis of Sorting Algorithms Using Multisets in Theorema

Proof-theoretic methods in quantifier-free definability

Characterizing Propositional Proofs As Non-Commutative Formulas.

Investigations into Proof Structures

Canonical Proof nets for Classical Logic

Weighted, Circular and Semi-Algebraic Proofs

On an elementary proof of the fundamental theorem of algebra

Kalmár-style constructive completeness proofs for classical positive propositional calculi

Graphical Calculi and their Conjecture Synthesis

Graphical Proof Theory I: Sequent Systems on Undirected Graphs