Older and younger adults are influenced differently by dark pattern designs

Reza Ghaiumy Anaraky,Byron Lowens,Yao Li,Kaileigh A. Byrne,Marten Risius,Xinru Page,Pamela Wisniewski,Masoumeh Soleimani,Morteza Soltani,Bart Knijnenburg

2023-10-06

Abstract:Considering that prior research has found older users undergo a different privacy decision-making process compared to younger adults, more research is needed to inform the behavioral privacy disclosure effects of these strategies for different age groups. To address this gap, we used an existing dataset of an experiment with a photo-tagging Facebook application. This experiment had a 2x2x5 between-subjects design where the manipulations were common dark pattern design strategies: framing (positive vs. negative), privacy defaults (opt-in vs. opt-out), and justification messages (positive normative, negative normative, positive rationale, negative rationale, none). We compared older (above 65 years old, N=44) and young adults (18 to 25 years old, N=162) privacy concerns and disclosure behaviors (i.e., accepting or refusing automated photo tagging) in the scope of dark pattern design. Overall, we find support for the effectiveness of dark pattern designs in the sense that positive framing and opt-out privacy defaults significantly increased disclosure behavior, while negative justification messages significantly decreased privacy concerns. Regarding older adults, our results show that certain dark patterns do lead to more disclosure than for younger adults, but also to increased privacy concerns for older adults than for younger.

Human-Computer Interaction

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### The Problem the Paper Attempts to Solve

This paper aims to explore the differences in privacy attitudes and behaviors between users of different age groups (elderly and young people) when faced with "dark pattern design." Specifically, the researchers utilize an existing experimental dataset to analyze the impact of different design strategies on users' privacy decisions, addressing the following two research questions:

1. **What is the impact of dark pattern design on user attitudes and behaviors?**
- The researchers aim to understand how common dark pattern design strategies (such as framing effects, default settings, and reason information) influence users' privacy concerns and information disclosure behaviors.

2. **What are the differences in attitudes and behaviors between elderly and young people when faced with dark pattern design?**
- The researchers are particularly interested in whether elderly and young people respond differently to the same dark pattern design and the specific manifestations of these differences.

### Background and Motivation

- **Age and Privacy Decisions**: Existing research indicates significant differences between elderly and young people in managing digital privacy. Elderly people tend to be more concerned about privacy issues but may face more difficulties in understanding and managing privacy settings.
- **Dark Pattern Design**: Dark pattern design refers to designers leveraging human psychological traits through certain design strategies (such as framing effects, default settings, and reason information) to induce users to disclose more information. These design strategies are widely used in e-commerce and marketing, but their impact on users of different age groups remains unclear.

### Methods

- **Experimental Design**: The researchers used an existing dataset from an experiment involving an automatic photo tagging Facebook application. The experiment employed a 2x2x5 between-subjects design, manipulating three common dark pattern design strategies: framing effects (positive vs. negative), default settings (opt-in vs. opt-out), and reason information (positive norm, negative norm, positive reason, negative reason, none).
- **Participants**: The experiment included 44 elderly participants (65 years and older) and 162 young participants (18 to 25 years old).
- **Dependent Variables**: The researchers measured participants' privacy concerns and photo tagging decisions (accept or reject automatic tagging).

### Main Findings

- **Overall Effect**: The results support the effectiveness of dark pattern design, particularly that positive framing and opt-out default settings significantly increased information disclosure behaviors, while negative reason information significantly reduced privacy concerns.
- **Differences Between Elderly and Young People**: Although elderly participants exhibited higher privacy concerns when faced with opt-out default settings, this concern did not affect their actual behavior. In contrast, dark pattern design had a greater impact on elderly participants, leading them to disclose more information than young participants.
- **Design Recommendations**: Based on these findings, the researchers proposed several design recommendations to better support the privacy protection of elderly users.

### Conclusion

This study reveals the different effects of dark pattern design on users of different age groups, emphasizing that designers should consider the special needs of elderly users when developing applications to avoid potential privacy risks.