Hidden Turbulence in van Gogh's \textbf{\textit{The Starry Night}}

Yinxiang Ma,Wanting Cheng,Shidi Huang,François G. Schmitt,Xin Lin,Yongxiang Huang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/5.0213627

2024-09-27

Abstract:Turbulent skies have often inspired artists, particularly in the iconic swirls of Vincent van Gogh's \textbf{\textit{The Starry Night}}. For an extended period, debate has raged over whether the flow pattern in this masterpiece adheres to Kolmogorov's theory of turbulence. In contrast to previous studies that examined only part of this painting, {\textit{all and only the}} whirls/eddies in the painting are taken into account in this work, following the Richardson-Kolmogorov's cascade picture of turbulence. Consequently, the luminance's Fourier power spectrum spontaneously exhibits a characteristic $-5/3$ Kolmogorov-like power-law. This result suggests that van Gogh had a very careful observation of real flows, so that not only the sizes of whirls/eddies in \textbf{\textit{The Starry Night}} but also their relative distances and intensity follow the physical law that governs turbulent flows. Moreover, a "$-1$"-like power-law persists in the spectrum below the scales of the smallest whirls, hinting at Batchelor-type scalar turbulence with a high Schmidt number. Our study thus unveils the hidden turbulence captured within \textbf{\textit{The Starry Night}}.

Fluid Dynamics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore whether the vortex patterns in Van Gogh's famous painting "The Starry Night" conform to the classical theory of turbulence. Specifically, the authors focus on the following points:

1. **Verification of Kolmogorov's Turbulence Theory**: Many previous studies have only examined parts of "The Starry Night", while this paper considers all the vortex structures in the painting to verify whether these patterns follow Kolmogorov's -5/3 power law. According to Kolmogorov's theory, in the so - called inertial range of fully developed turbulence, the Fourier power spectrum \(E(k)\) should satisfy the following relationship:
\[
E(k)\propto\epsilon^{2/3}k^{-5/3}
\]
where \(\epsilon\) is the average energy dissipation rate and \(k\) is the wavenumber.

2. **Verification of Batchelor's Scalar Turbulence Theory**: On a smaller scale, the paper also explores whether there is Batchelor - type scalar turbulence, which is characterized by a power law of - 1. This corresponds to the case of a high Schmidt number (Sc), where the Schmidt number is defined as:
\[
Sc = \frac{\nu}{\kappa}
\]
where \(\nu\) is the fluid viscosity and \(\kappa\) is the scalar diffusivity. For a high Sc number, Batchelor predicts that in the viscous - convective range, the power spectrum \(E_{\theta}(k)\) obeys:
\[
E_{\theta}(k)=C_{B}\epsilon_{\theta}\left(\frac{\nu}{\epsilon}\right)^{1/2}k^{-1}\exp\left(-C_{B}\left(\frac{k}{k_{B}}\right)^{2}\right),\quad k\gg k_{\eta}
\]

3. **Characterization of Multiscale Features**: By analyzing all the vortex structures in "The Starry Night", the authors hope to reveal whether these patterns follow the real turbulence laws not only in size but also in relative distance and intensity. This helps to understand whether Van Gogh captured the essential features of turbulence in his painting through careful observation of real flows.

In summary, this paper aims to verify, through strict scientific methods, whether the vortex patterns in "The Starry Night" are consistent with the classical theory of turbulence and further explore the physical mechanisms behind them.