Abstract:Due to their capacity to generate novel and high-quality samples, diffusion models have attracted significant research interest in recent years. Notably, the typical training objective of diffusion models, i.e., denoising score matching, has a closed-form optimal solution that can only generate training data replicating samples. This indicates that a memorization behavior is theoretically expected, which contradicts the common generalization ability of state-of-the-art diffusion models, and thus calls for a deeper understanding. Looking into this, we first observe that memorization behaviors tend to occur on smaller-sized datasets, which motivates our definition of effective model memorization (EMM), a metric measuring the maximum size of training data at which a learned diffusion model approximates its theoretical optimum. Then, we quantify the impact of the influential factors on these memorization behaviors in terms of EMM, focusing primarily on data distribution, model configuration, and training procedure. Besides comprehensive empirical results identifying the influential factors, we surprisingly find that conditioning training data on uninformative random labels can significantly trigger the memorization in diffusion models. Our study holds practical significance for diffusion model users and offers clues to theoretical research in deep generative models. Code is available at <a class="link-external link-https" href="https://github.com/sail-sg/DiffMemorize" rel="external noopener nofollow">this https URL</a>.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve
This paper aims to explore the memorization behavior in Diffusion Models. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following two main issues:
1. **The gap between theory and practice**: The standard training objective of diffusion models—Denoising Score Matching (DSM)—has a closed-form optimal solution that can only generate samples by replicating the training data. This suggests that memorization behavior is theoretically expected, but it contradicts the generalization ability usually exhibited by state-of-the-art diffusion models. This contradiction prompts researchers to delve into the conditions under which diffusion models adhere to this theoretical optimal solution, thereby exhibiting memorization behavior.
2. **Factors influencing memorization behavior**: To better understand memorization behavior in diffusion models, the paper quantifies the impact of several key factors on memorization behavior, including data distribution, model configuration, and the training process. In particular, the study finds that conditioning the training data with uninformative random labels can significantly trigger memorization behavior in diffusion models.
### Main Contributions
- **Definition of Effective Model Memorization (EMM)**: EMM is a metric that measures the maximum amount of training data a diffusion model can approximate its theoretical optimal solution after training.
- **Experimental validation**: Through a series of experiments, the paper validates the impact of factors such as dataset size, number of training epochs, model width and depth, time embedding methods, and skip connections on memorization behavior.
- **Theoretical analysis**: The paper provides a theoretical analysis from the perspective of the backward process, further explaining the mechanism of memorization behavior.
### Experimental Results
- **Dataset size**: Smaller datasets are more likely to lead to memorization behavior. For example, on the CIFAR-10 dataset, when the dataset size is reduced to 5k or 2k, the model exhibits significant memorization behavior.
- **Number of training epochs**: More training epochs also increase the probability of memorization behavior occurring.
- **Model configuration**: Increasing the model width significantly enhances EMM, while the impact of model depth is not monotonic.
- **Time embedding**: Using Fourier features for time embedding significantly reduces memorization behavior.
- **Skip connections**: Skip connections at high resolutions contribute more to memorization behavior, and increasing the number of skip connections does not always enhance memorization behavior.
### Practical Significance
- **User guidance**: The research results have practical significance for users of diffusion models, helping them better understand and control the memorization behavior of models in practical applications.
- **Theoretical research clues**: The study provides theoretical research clues about the memorization behavior of deep generative models, aiding further exploration of the generalization ability and potential risks of models.
In summary, this paper reveals the complexity of memorization behavior in diffusion models through systematic experiments and theoretical analysis, providing valuable references for future related research.