Revisiting the Thomas-Fermi Potential for Three-Dimensional Condensed Matter Systems

Gionni Marchetti
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1140/epjb/s10051-024-00711-6
2024-06-24
Abstract:We proposed a formally exact, probabilistic method to assess the validity of the Thomas-Fermi potential for three-dimensional condensed matter systems where electron dynamics is constrained to the Fermi surface. Our method, which relies on accurate solutions of the radial Schrödinger equation, yields the probability density function for momentum transfer. This allows for the computation of its expectation values, which can be compared with unity to confirm the validity of the Thomas-Fermi approximation. We applied this method to three {\it n}-type direct-gap III-V model semiconductors (GaAs, InAs, InSb) and found that the Thomas-Fermi approximation is certainly valid at high electron densities. In these cases, the probability density function exhibits the same profile, irrespective of the material under scrutiny. Furthermore, we show that this approximation can lead to serious errors in the computation of observables when applied to GaAs at zero temperature for most electron densities under scrutiny.
Materials Science
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper mainly discusses the applicability of the Thomas-Fermi potential in three-dimensional condensed matter systems. The author proposes an accurate probabilistic approach to evaluate the effectiveness of the Thomas-Fermi potential in systems where electronic dynamics are limited to the Fermi surface. This method is based on the exact solution of the radial Schrödinger equation and can calculate the probability density function of momentum transfer, thus verifying it by comparing its expected value with unity. In this study, the author applies this method to analyze three direct bandgap III-V semiconductors (gallium arsenide, indium arsenide, and indium antimonide) and finds that the Thomas-Fermi potential is effective at high electron densities. The shape of the probability density function is independent of the material, with an expected value of about 0.3. However, at low to moderate electron densities, the use of the Thomas-Fermi potential may lead to significant errors for gallium arsenide. The paper also reviews the analysis potentials under the random phase approximation (RPA), pointing out that both the Thomas-Fermi potential and the exponential cosine potential are approximations of the RPA potential but lack electronic structural information from the Lindhard function. The author calculates the quantum scattering phase shift using numerical methods, establishes the probability density function of momentum transfer, and finds that this function shows similar patterns for all materials at high electron densities, supporting the applicability of the Thomas-Fermi potential in metallic states. In conclusion, the paper provides a rigorous method to assess the effectiveness of the Thomas-Fermi potential, highlighting its limitations under specific conditions, and points out that the use of the Thomas-Fermi potential may lead to inaccurate results in certain cases, such as low temperatures and low electron densities in gallium arsenide.